Host: Jay Allison
[overture music]
Jay: [00:00:12] From PRX, this is The Moth Radio Hour. I am Jay Allison. And in this show, we are hearing about the way we see ourselves versus the way others see us. Spoiler alert, they are not always the same.
Our first story comes from Enrique García Naranjo, who told this live on stage at the Mesa Arts Center in Arizona. Here is Enrique.
[cheers and applause]
Enrique: [00:00:41] So, I am getting ready for this poetry performance in front of 60 to 70 high school students in Douglas, Arizona. A town that sits about five minutes away from the US-Mexico border. I am getting ready to read this poem I wrote about my barrio, the barrio I lived in for the majority of my teenage years. As I am getting ready for this poem, I look into the crowd and I see all the sleepy and uninterested faces. Quickly I win them over with this poem I wrote about the holiness of tacos and the unrelenting spirit of Mexican grandmothers. And right after that poem, I ask them to pull out pencils and paper for them to write. I give them a prompt, one of my favorite prompts when I am doing this sort of thing, The city within my chest.
And after that, I leave the school with my partner, Selena, who drove up there with me. I am reflecting on the students and their poems. Specifically on the way they wrote these poems, right, bilingually, in English and Spanish. A real reflection of who they are as people, people between cultures, between languages, fronterizas y fronterizos, people of the border. As we are on our way back to Tucson and the entire workshop still fresh in my mind, we are passing Tombstone, Arizona, where a border patrol checkpoint sits. If you have been there, you know that there are quite a few border patrol checkpoints.
As we are passing it, I notice that it is closed, which is a rare sight. So, I try to make sure that I am not seeing an illusion. As I am doing that, I look in the rearview and I see a car catching up to us, speeding up. As I am trying to do all these things at the same time, and peering into the rearview and seeing who might be following us, I see the flash of red and white blue lights. At first, I think it is a cop. But as we park and I see the officers step out of the vehicle, I see the green of their uniform and I realize it is border patrol. My shoulders tense and my heart drops. And instantly in my head, I run the instructions my dad gave me when I was younger, if I were ever apprehended by migra, do these three things. Sit up, look the officer in the eye, answer all the questions.
In third grade, there was a white boy who stood up in class and started yelling, "I am going to call border patrol and deport all the Mexicans in school." I remember running as fast as my brown feet would allow with tears in my eyes, hoping I got home to make sure that my parents were still there, because I lived in that reality. I was born on this side, the American side, which makes me a citizen. But the majority of my family are undocumented. We are a mixed-status family. So, I grew up with their stories of crossing the border, of what border patrol does to people who look like me. And it was terrifying. We lived in the shadows. And in the shadows, silence is survival.
So, all this is running in my head. I see the officer walking towards us and I realize, yeah, I am a citizen. But Selena, my partner, is undocumented. Although she has DACA, Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, and technically we got documentation that allows us and permits us to be here legally, documents fall flat in situations like this. Documents don’t change the color of our skin. So, the officer shows up to the window. I put the window down to engage with the officer, and I notice his gun. I immediately think about José Antonio Elena, a 16-year-old Mexican killed by border patrol in Nogales for holding rocks in his hand. I am stunned in that fear and that disempowerment of not knowing how the situation would end up.
So, the officer begins the interaction, asking us what our business is in Tombstone, where we are coming from, where we are going, and asks Selena where she is from. Selena says, "Oakland." "Oakland? Oh, man. Are you going to stab me?" We are both like, “What the hell?” Selena says, "No,” thankfully. [audience laughter] So, then he proceeds to ask if he could go to the trunk to check if we had a dead body in the back. Again chuckling and again us being like, “What’s going on? What the hell?” So, I am like, “All right, man.” I open up the trunk, he goes back to review it and I realize he is making jokes. He is making this a lighthearted situation.
And for him, that’s the reality. But for us, at any moment, we trip up, at any moment we give him more suspicion, because we already, suspicion being brown, three things can happen in that situation. Detention, deportation, death. I know the stories. I have heard them. It is not unheard of for brown folks to go to those things, citizens or undocumented. So, he comes back to the window, Selena's passenger side, and says, "Well, you two look like you could be American citizens. Have a pleasant day," and he lets us go. As we are driving off, Selena is boiling in her seat, breaking down every instance of that situation, running it by me. And I am quiet.
I am running that sentence over and over and over in my head, "You two look like you could be citizens." But what good does that do me? How can I look like a citizen if I was stopped precisely for the reason of how I look? And it always comes to this for a fronterizo or a fronteriza, always on the brink of being, always having to prove that we are something. I think of that old Mexican saying, “Ni de aquí, ni de allá,” not from here, not from there. And this flux and this brink that we exist in.
I think about the students in Douglas. I think about their poems, and their bravery to write their narrative and the way they speak. I think about my parents, I think about Selena, I think about myself and I realize how we as fronterizos y fronterizas are caught in this flux between citizen and alien, between silence and disruption, between here and there. All told, the situation with the officer lasted about 10 minutes and never escalated far beyond the awkwardness and the microaggressions. And through it all, Selena and I were happy that we still had our lives. The thing we could have lost at that moment, if anything. We are happy, for the most part, that we are still free.
[cheers and applause]
Jay: [00:08:38] Enrique García Naranjo is an artist and culture worker based in Tucson, Arizona. García Naranjo's art and organizing centers on music and literature as tools for liberation and empowerment for marginalized young people. Enrique says, "I was able to leave that situation and continue living my life. A lot of folks are not granted that privilege."
[softhearted music]
We will be back in a moment with three SLAM stories about how we are seen by others, when The Moth Radio Hour continues.
[softhearted music]
The Moth Radio Hour is produced by Atlantic Public Media in Woods Hole, Massachusetts. And it is presented by PRX.
[softhearted music]
This is The Moth Radio Hour from PRX. I am Jay Allison. And in this hour, we are hearing stories about how we see ourselves versus how others see us.
The next three stories come from our open-mic StorySLAM series around the country, where anyone in the audience can literally throw their name in a hat for the chance to get on stage and tell a story. SLAMs give everyone a chance, first-timers and seasoned tellers alike, and also let the audience connect with strangers who take the stage, people who may have been sitting right next to them for the whole show.
Our first slammer is Aydrea Walden, who told this story in Los Angeles, where we partner with Public Radio Station KCRW. Here's Aydrea, live at The Moth.
[applause]
Aydrea: [00:11:58] So, it's the fourth grade, and I am super in love with Spencer Williams. He sits next to me in homeroom, and he's so cute, and he's got this messy red hair and these blue eyes and a mask of freckles across his nose. We spend the whole first half of the year getting in trouble all the time, because we can't stop talking to each other during class. So, for the second half of the year, we start passing notes in class, so we don't get caught, which is amazing, because Spencer never passed notes in class before, which means I'm changing him, just like a good girlfriend should. [audience laughter]
And this one time, we're on a field trip, and I fell down, and he reached down to help me up and when he gave me his hand, he didn't let go right away. And in fourth grade, that's basically over-the-clothes second base. [audience laughter] It was very exciting. And the school we go to is one of these experimental, like magnet models, where we can call our teachers by their first names and we have classes like outdoors or in graveyards. [audience laughter] In addition to math and English, we have classes like enrichment and future thinking. We both go to this very progressive school, and so I think that we are a very progressive couple, and our relationship is progressing just like I want it. [audience laughter.
Until one day I'm sitting at recess, like, hanging out by myself, and this gaggle of girls rushes up to me, which is exciting, because gaggles of girls never rush up to me. So, I take out my Trapper Keeper, so I can write all their phone numbers down. And they're like, "Aydrea, Aydrea, are you going around with Vincent?" And going around was our word for dating at that time. And I was like, "I don't know who Vincent is, but did you guys want it?" And then, they were gone. [audience laughter] And I was like, “All right.” I forgot about it and went back to my Choose Your Own Adventure book or whatever. [audience laughter]
And then, later that afternoon, another group of girls comes up and they're like, "Aydrea, are you going around with Vincent?" I'm like, "I still don't know who Vincent is, but do you guys want--" and then they were gone. I was a little upset, because I felt like mean girls being mean. But in terms of what bullying could be, it wasn't really that bad. [audience laughter] So, I let it go, until choir rehearsal that afternoon, like, after school. One of my very good friends was like, "Aydrea, I hear you're going around with Vincent." And I was like, "Okay, who is Vincent? Also, we're nine, maybe it's cool if we don't have boyfriends yet."
And she's like, "I can't believe you don't know who that is," and she points to the back of the cafeteria where these boys are doing boy things. I was like, "I don't know who you're talking about. Is it that blonde kid with the red shorts?" And she's like, "No, dummy, next to him." And I'm like, "The guy with the ponytail and Converse?" And she's like, "No, in front of him." And I'm like, "Buzzcut and tank top?" She's like, "No, Aydrea, the Black kid. Vincent is that Black kid. You should totally make him a Boyz II Men mixtape." I was like, "Oh, well, I already like Spencer, and I've already made him a Pixies mixtape, so I'm good on mixtapes." [audience laughter]
And she's like, "Why would you like Spencer?" And I was like, "Why would I like Vincent?" And she was like, "Because, you know." And the bummer was that I did know, because fourth grade was the year that I learned that I was Black. It was a huge surprise to me. [audience laughter] I had no idea. I had no idea. I didn't know that people had opinions on that or that it sometimes mattered, because up until then, I just didn't know. When I would draw pictures of myself, I just wanted my pictures to look like everyone else's pictures, so I gave myself peach skin or pink skin, and nobody cared.
And then, one time, the first time I heard the N-word was in a funny little song someone was singing in the hallway, because it's rural Texas and that shit happens. [audience laughter] I sang it for my mom, and I did not understand why she was livid. And fourth grade was also the year that some asshole decided we were going to start celebrating Black History Month, which amounted to me just, like, trembling in the corner through the whole month of February while my teachers showed us pictures of backs with scars all over them and fire hoses and German shepherds.
Every other set of eyes in the room would look at me and be like, "Aydrea, we're sorry. What was it like?" [audience laughter] And I'm like, "You guys, you guys are not even 10 yet. The worst thing that's happened to me is not being able to go to any New Kids On The Block concert, because I was grounded. [audience laughter] Just leave me alone." And this whole thing with Vincent was this weird natural extension of that, because Vincent, it was his first week at school that week, and he was the only other Black kid in my class of a hundred or so.
It was baffling to me that nobody, even though I got in trouble for talking to Spencer every day, nobody had any idea that I had a crush on him. Even though I had not said one word to Vincent, no one could figure out why we weren't basically married. Like, nobody, including Spencer. Because that week, he came up to me and was like, "Hey, Aydrea, you left your Caboodle in Future Thinking." [audience laughter] And I was like, "Thank you," because that felt like excellent eventual boyfriend behavior and was very happy, until he told me that he was playing soccer with Vincent and he could totally give him my number if I wanted.
And then, even our teachers got into it. This one teacher after school was like, "Well, Aydrea, have we seen the new student, and do we have a little crush on Vincent?" And I was like, "No, Diana, [audience laughter] we do not have a crush on Vincent. We did not have a crush on Vincent or anyone else anymore.” Thank you.
[cheers and applause]
Jay: [00:17:14] That was Aydrea Walden. Aydrea is a writer and performer living in Los Angeles. She is the creator of the Webby-nominated, Jane Austen themed web series called Black Girl in a Big Dress. She is happy to share her Pixies playlist with anyone.
[softhearted music]
Next up is Miles Crabtree, who comes to us from our Detroit SLAM, which is supported by Public Radio Station WDET. Here's Miles.
[cheers and applause]
Miles: [00:18:06] I was nine years old when it was announced that my fourth-grade class was going to be putting on the production, How the West Was Won. So, our music teachers handed out the scripts, so we could decide if we wanted to audition for a speaking part, which I, of course, did. I looked through the script, read through it and I decided I wanted to be the newsboy, because I wanted to wear the cool newsboy cap and run out on stage with a newspaper yelling, “Extra, extra, read all about it!”
So, we had a week to prepare. So, I go home, I memorize the line, I prepare all these cool moves, and when the day comes, I go into auditions and I give it my most enthusiastic performance. The only other kid to go out for the same part just mumbles the line into his shoes. So, I figure, I've got this one in the bag. This is my part. However, when I come into school the next day, I'm informed that the other kid who tried out is getting the part, because the newsboy is really supposed to be played by a boy. You see, I'm transgender. So, when I was in the fourth grade, I was actually a little girl. Everyone saw me as a little girl. That's not how I saw myself and that is not the part that I wanted to play, but that is the part that I was forced into.
So, I was told that I was going to be playing the part of Prairie Girl Number Three or something like that. Thank God for whoever made that casting decision, because we wouldn't want the parents of Melrose Elementary School to be accosted with an unrealistic portrayal of the history of the Western United States, right? [audience laughter] [audience cheers and applause]
I can only imagine the chaos that would have ensued. [audience laughter] "Becky, did you see the fourth-grade production of How the West Was Won?" "Sarah, I did, and let me tell you, I was completely enthralled until that little butch girl ran out on stage as a newsboy. [audience laughter] Talk about having to suspend my disbelief." [audience laughter] So, anyway, I sat all through those rehearsals wearing a bonnet and a scowl. [audience laughter] I had to pretend to knit during the entire show. I had some one line that I can't even remember now. But I was so filled with joy when our one and only production of How the West Was Won was marred by technical difficulties. [audience laughter]
You see, as fourth graders, we'd made the set ourselves. We painted this glorious backdrop on butcher paper that hung at the back of our stage. Finger painted. It was very heavy from all the paint. And so, during our one and only production, it began to fall down on top of all of us like a tsunami. [audience laughter] But because I was at the front, I was untouched, wearing a bonnet and a smile. Thank you.
[cheers and applause]
Jay: [00:21:16] That was Miles Crabtree. Miles tells us he went on to act in nearly all of his high school’s theater productions and was finally able to play a male role for the first time in his junior year of college, 12 years after How the West Was Won. Miles’s love of working with young people, the great outdoors, and song parodies has led him to become an educator and career camp counselor. He is training to become a music therapist. According to his campers, if Miles were an animal, he’d be a sea lion.
[whimsical music]
Our next storyteller is Kimberly Rose, who told this story at our Boston SLAM, where we’re supported by WBUR and PRX. Here’s Kimberly, live at The Moth.
[cheers and applause]
Kimberly: [00:22:16] I was sitting outside CVS. I had just gotten a packet of photos from my daughter’s fourth birthday. It was a big packet of photos. This was like 2009, when people still went to CVS to get photos. At least, 60 photos. I was looking through them, and was really excited. There were pictures of my daughter and my other two kids, and my husband, who was the family photographer, but somehow, he still got in the picture, and their grandparents. And none of me. So, I kept looking, and not even a picture of me and my daughter and I thought for sure there must have been a mistake. I would have bet a million dollars there was a mistake. And back then, they used to give you an index, which was basically thumbnails of your photos.
I was sure it was one of those underdeveloped photos, you know how CVS used to take sort of executive decisions and decide, “This photo will not be developed, because it’s too low light, and it’s black.” I thought, oh, they just didn’t develop it. This can’t be possible. But it was. And so, sitting in that car, looking through those photos, I realized that there were no photos of me. That’s how my husband wanted the photo album of his life to be. All of a sudden, I realized that I was never in the photos, hardly at all. There were no framed photos of me in our entire house. After eight years of marriage, I was like a ghost.
When I met him, we were madly in love. I knew by our fourth date we were going to get married. He was 6’2”, muscular, [chuckles] honest, wanted to get married, a good Jewish boy, a doctor to boot. I was the perfect Jewish suburban housewife. I kept kosher. I had five sets of pots and pans. I went to parenting classes and parenting resilient children classes, and parent-teacher association meetings and Zumba class and gluten-ab classes, marriage counseling, and we even went to the rabbi. [chuckles] I did everything I was supposed to.
But I remembered an earlier time where we had gone next door to dinner, and our neighbors had pulled out. We’d started talking about honeymoons for some reason and they pulled out their honeymoon album. There were all these pictures of the bride. I felt sick, because at that point I’d only been married two years and I realized there were no photos of me from my honeymoon like that. I think at one point, I forced him to take a picture of me, because I was so happy I could fit into a La Perla bikini. But other than that, nothing like this. There was one photo in particular of her looking into the camera with these dewy eyes and so much love in her eyes. I didn’t have anything like that. I had nothing.
Sitting there in that car, in that CVS, I realized I was never going to get that. I was never going to get that kind of love, I was never going to be seen and I was disappearing. One of the first things I did after my divorce, was I hired a top national photographer- [audience laughter] [audience cheers] -that I could not afford. At that point, I was a single mom with three kids. I didn’t have time to go shopping. I was not at my lowest weight and I was not tan. And it didn’t matter. They were very, very tasteful boudoir glamour shots. [audience laughter] They were awesome. [audience laughter] It was the best thing I ever did. I’ll never forget the day that those photos came by email, and I couldn’t stop crying. It was as if my soul exploded, and I had come out of the corners and the shadows and out of the slivers and the frames into the light.
[cheers and applause]
Jay: [00:26:16] That was Kimberly Rose. Kimberly is a short story author, playwright and screenwriter. She's working on a short film based on some of her stories. She told us that this experience relaunched her self-esteem and her writing career. To see some of those photos, visit themoth.org. By the way, Kimberly says she has plenty of photos of her three kids too, all of them in focus.
[softhearted music]
Coming up, our final story about the ways we see ourselves. This one takes place on the set of Saturday Night Live, when The Moth Radio Hour continues.
[softhearted music]
The Moth Radio Hour is produced by Atlantic Public Media in Woods Hole, Massachusetts. And is presented by the Public Radio Exchange, prx.org.
[softhearted music]
You're listening to The Moth Radio Hour from PRX. I'm Jay Allison. And we're hearing stories about how we see ourselves and whether it's an accurate view.
Our final story is a Moth favorite from Jessi Klein. Jessi told the story at a live event held at SummerStage outside in New York City's Central Park. So, if you hear birds or trucks or planes, that's why. Over 4,000 people were there listening to the stories, many sitting on picnic blankets as the sun went down. A brief note in advance. This story contains funny stuff about sex. Here's Jessi Klein, live from New York.
[cheers and applause]
Jessi: [00:29:38] One of my happiest memories as a kid, around nine years old, was of staying up late to watch Saturday Night Live on this old black-and-white TV that I had actually found in the trash area of my building and had convinced my parents to let me keep in my room mainly, so that I could stay up and watch Saturday Night Live. There was just something so magical and exciting to me about when that show would start and that theme music would play over that cool New Yorky montage of the cast. It just made me feel really hip and alive, like I was part of a cool club, and not a nerdy girl who was watching a black-and-white TV that I found in the garbage. [chuckles]
So, one of the highlights from when I was 10 years old, and full disclosure, there are no other highlights from when I was [chuckles] 10 years old, because I was 10. But one of the highlights was that my best friend's dad took us to 30 Rock to see a taping of SNL. I remember that before the show started, I had to go to the bathroom. And to get there, I walked down the hallway of Studio 8H, and it was lined with photos of Gilda Radner and Bill Murray, and I was just like, “Oh, my God, oh, my God, oh, my God they were here, I'm here. Oh, my God.”
When I got to the bathroom, I took 15 paper towels and put them into my pocket to bring home and put into this little wooden box I had, where I kept all of my mementos. [audience laughter] It had a unicorn on it. It was beautiful. I think the only other memento in the box at the time was an acorn I had picked up on a trip to Woodstock. But anyway, on that visit to SNL, the host was Tom Hanks and the musical guest was Aerosmith. So, it was awesome.
Just when the night couldn't get any more perfect, afterwards, my friend's dad took us to an incredible dinner at Hard Rock Cafe, the coolest restaurant in the world. I remember so clearly, it was the first velvet rope I ever walked past. As I was walking past it, I was like, I feel famous. [audience laughter] I feel like Justine Bateman must feel all the time. [audience laughter] So, [chuckles] the most famous woman in the world to me at the time.
So, cut to 2009. I am a grown-up. I have achieved, largely because of the influence of SNL, I have achieved my dream of becoming a professional TV comedy writer and I’m a stand-up comedian. I’ve been working in LA for three years, and I’m finally moving back to New York, mainly because LA is sunny and perfect and I hate it and I can’t live there anymore. [audience laughter] But anyway, I’m back in New York and I need a job. My agent calls me out of the blue and he’s like, “You know, SNL is actually looking for new writers right now. Do you want to submit some sketches?” And I was like, “Oh, my God, yes, of course I do. I just have to find them on my computer.” By find them on my computer, I meant I had to run to Starbucks and panic and write some [chuckles] sketches.
It's really hard to write anything comedy at Starbucks, because there's no one around to tell you if your commercial parody idea for a jockstrap for dogs is funny or not. And if you're wondering, “Did you really submit a sketch that was a commercial parody for a jockstrap for dogs?” the answer is yes. Yes, I did. I was like, “All right. Well, I'm not going to get this job.” But then, a couple of days later, my agent calls me again, and he's like, “SNL liked your packet. You need to meet with Lorne Michaels.”
So, I'm not going to gossip about Lorne, but I'll just give [chuckles] you a representative tidbit from the interview I had with him, which is, you know, I'm a little nervous, but I go into his office and it's one of those situations-- I don't know if you've ever been in an interview like this, but there's a very large leather couch and then also a large [chuckles] leather chair and I never know where to sit in that situation, so I just decide I'm going to be endearing and honest, and I'm like, “So, where do you want me to sit?” And he's like, “Well, why don't you sit on the couch and I'll sit on the chair.” And I'm like, “Okay.”
And then, we have a minute of small talk. And after a minute, he goes, “You know, actually, I want to sit on the couch.” [audience laughter] I look to see if he's joking, and he's not. We got up and we switched, [audience laughter] and I was like, “This is weird.” And then, 15 minutes later, I left. I was like, not only am I not getting that job, I almost feel like I've been fired from the job. [audience laughter] I don't know how that would work.
But then, a few days later, I am home and I am lying on my couch watching Animal Planet, as is my want. [chuckles] I get another call from my agent. And he's like, “Yeah, so, you got the job. SNL wants you, and you're going to start-- [audience applause]
Thanks. Wait till you hear the rest of the story. [audience laughter] So, anyway, I flip out and I call my best friend, John, and he comes over and we order pizza. I put on Jay-Z’s Empire State of Mind [audience laughter] and I put it on repeat, because that’s what people do when they’re happy now. [audience laughter]
I’m having one of those, very sort of that special moment in life. I’m having that window in between when you get a cool job and you can tell everyone about it, but right before you’ve started the job and you realize what the job is going to entail. I was not prepared for what working at SNL entailed. So, I’ll just give you a little brief picture of how the week works.
Basically, it starts on Tuesday, and the writers stay up all night to write the whole show. Literally, all night. Like, you get there at noon and you go home at 09:00 AM Wednesday morning, like, at best. Maybe you’ll go home and you’ll sleep for a couple of hours, but then you have to come back to prepare for Wednesday afternoon’s table read, which is this epic marathon affair in which Lorne, and the whole cast, and all the writers and everyone who works at the show squishes into the writers’ room and they read every single sketch that’s been submitted. There’s about 40, and it takes about four hours.
And afterwards, [chuckles] Lorne goes off with the supervising writers, and it takes them a few hours. They decide what’s going to go in that week’s show based on what got the most laughs. They have this weird tradition where even though there’s email now, the way they let you know what’s going to be in the show is they do it high school play style, where the writer assistant comes out with one piece of paper, and everyone has to crowd around [audience laughter] to see what’s been circled.
When I would ask people, “Why do we do it this way?” people would be like, “It’s just tradition.” My first Tuesday night, my first writer’s night, I’m excited but a little nervous, because I’m remembering that I am not a night person. I am a morning person. I go to bed at 10:30 PM every night. But I’m like, “All right, I’m just going to power through.” I’m powering through, and then at about 10:35, I’m like, I’m so sleepy. [audience laughter] But my work was not anywhere close to done, because the host for that week was Blake Lively, the lead girl from Gossip Girl. She seemed super cool and funny and really nice.
I was writing this sketch where I decided she would play a wacky volunteer at an animal adoption center. I don't know why, but I thought that would work. So, I was just really anal about making it perfect. I stay up all night tweaking it, and the hours are dragging on and on. So, in a nutshell, my first table read at Saturday Night Live, it bombs so bad. The sketch bombs so bad in front of a room of people who I think are the funniest people in the world. I'm assuming that probably there's a few of you here [chuckles] who have never bombed in front of the writers' room [chuckles] at SNL. So, just to give you a sense of what it's like. [audience laughter]
Imagine that you're having sex with somebody that you really like, but they're not making any noise, [chuckles] no matter what you do to their body with your body. [audience laughter] And then, imagine that there's also a room of people watching it happen, [audience laughter] and they're not making any noise either. [audience laughter] It's terrifying. And it's so terrifying that I'm like, “This will not stand.” I'm determined that next week I'm going to get something at least onto the dress rehearsal show.
So, a little background on that. Every Saturday, SNL actually does two shows, and the first show is in front of a studio audience, but it doesn't air. And any sketch that doesn't do well will not make it to the TV show. So, I'm like, “I'm going to at least get that far.” [chuckles] The host my second week is Taylor Lautner, who's the teen heartthrob werewolf from the Twilight movies, which I have not seen. One, because I am 35 years old, [audience laughter] and two, because if I want to see pale people being angsty, I'll go home for Shabbat dinner [audience laughter] and just stare at my parents or look in the mirror. I don't need to spend money. But he seems really nice, and he's really young, so I'm like, “I'll write something or he plays someone really young.”
So, I write a sketch where he'll play Bristol Palin's ex, Levi Johnston. All he's going to have to do is wear a puffy vest and mumble like an idiot. Taylor Lautner nails this. [chuckles] It gets laughs, and it goes to dress rehearsal, and I'm like, “Oh, this is a victory,” or so I think, until I realize what dress rehearsal means, which is Lorne basically sits-- Mr. Lorne Michaels sits under the audience bleachers during dress, and he watches the show on a monitor. When your sketch starts, you slide into a chair next to Lorne and you watch your sketch with him.
So, my sketch starts, and then I watch Lorne watch my sketch bomb really bad. [audience laughter] I'm assuming there's a few of you who've never watched your sketch bomb in front of Lorne. So, just to give you a sense of what it's like. [audience laughter] Imagine that you're having sex with Lorne Michaels, [audience laughter] and he's not making any noise. So, this becomes my life, right? Week after week, I am struggling to come up with material that I think will work on the show. It doesn't always go terribly, but I can never get it to go great. I start to spiral, because my whole identity, personally and professionally up to this point in my life, is that I am funny. I can be funny. It's just like, all of a sudden, I can't crack the code on this show.
Before every table read, I am gripped with fear. Before every dress rehearsal, my stomach is in knots. I am walking around lost and confused, but in a foggy way, in a Keanu Reeves way. [audience laughter] It just feels like there's a part of me that has become broken. And without it, I'm becoming unhinged, you know? First of all, I'm never seeing my friends anymore just because of the hours. And on the rare occasions when I see them, they say things to me like, "You don't look very good." Or like, "Jessi, don't cry in this restaurant. We want to come back here." [audience laughter] I'm also not sleeping, because there's no time to sleep. And on the occasions when I might sleep, I'm too anxious and I'm just thinking about next week's guest and what I should write for them and I'll be lying there like, "Okay, Jennifer Lopez is going to be on next week. What should I write for Jennifer Lopez?"
And in the midst of all the stress, I'm trying to experience any kind of pleasure. I don't have pleasure anymore. All I can do is go to the Anthropologie store downstairs at 30 Rock and spend too much money. I remember I spent $280 on a sweater with a kangaroo pocket on it. [chuckles] Girls know what I'm talking about. I knew I was hitting rock bottom when the anxiety started to affect me physically and I started to feel like I was having heart palpitations. Because I'm a neurotic hypochondriac, I was like, “I'm dying.”
So I went to my doctor. I have a really good doctor. So, he was immediately able to diagnose me with being an idiot. [audience laughter] And he's like, "You just need to relax." And I was like, "Okay. Well, then give me some Klonopin." And he was like, "No, you should do this without drugs." And I was like, "Why are you a bad doctor?" [audience laughter]
So, around this time, a really good friend of mine, the one who told me not to cry in restaurants, sends me a link to this series of lectures by this British Buddhist monk named Ajahn Brahm. And he's like, "Listen to this. It will make you feel better." I was skeptical, because generally the only self-help I will accept is from a very close girlfriend of mine named Oprah Winfrey. [audience laughter] But I'm desperate, so I'm like, “Okay.” I immediately fall in love with Ajahn Brahm. Basically, he has given a weekly talk for 15 years about every aspect of human experience in the world. They're alphabetized on the website, go look.
So, if your name is Mandy, you can look under M and there will probably be a lecture entitled, "Mandy, here's what you should do." [audience laughter] It's really helpful. So, I start listening to these lectures in bed. Literally, I take my laptop and I put it by my pillow, so his voice is in my ear. And one night, I listened to a lecture he did about death and dying. And the theme was Acceptance. It was accepting that life and death go together and are part of the same continuum. I realized even though I'm not physically dying, maybe I can integrate this sort of idea into the fact that my comedy is dying. [chuckles] I realized if I'm going to succeed at SNL, I have to make peace with bombing.
You have to do that in life, is make peace with bombing. But especially on that show. I stop writing things from a place of fear and what should I do, and I just start to write things that I think are funny and then I'm like, “Whatever,” and I hand it in. And things start to get better. One of the last shows of the season, Tina Fey was the host. I love Tina Fey, and I really wanted to get something on when she was on. I remembered on Tuesday night that I'd written this sketch when I was submitting to get the job, and I was like, “Maybe Tina would be good for this.” I hand it in, and we do it at table read. It doesn't kill, but it doesn't bomb. And it turns out Tina wants to try it.
It's a commercial parody. Not jockstrap for dogs. [audience laughter] It's a commercial parody, which means we're going to shoot it for Friday and edit all day Saturday. I remember sliding in next to Lorne right before dress. I was nervous that people weren't necessarily going to get it, because it was a weird idea and it was a parody of Duncan Hines commercials, and the way they show lonely women substituting chocolate for sex. And so, it was for a product called Brownie Husband. [audience laughter] And the idea was that it was like a brownie shaped like a husband and you could sort of fuck it and eat it at the same time. [audience laughter] I was nervous. But then, as soon as they started to roll it, people started to laugh.
They were really laughing, rolling hard laughter. Lorne is laughing. If you want to know what it's like [audience laughter] to make Lorne laugh, picture yourself having sex with Lorne and he's laughing. [audience laughter] And then, when it airs, it's a hit and it becomes a trending topic on Twitter. People want a Brownie Husband. Anyway, it was the first moment in the whole SNL experience when I was like, “Oh, this is what I thought it would be like when I was a kid.” So, the season ends.
The other SNL tradition, is that they don't tell you until the end of the summer if you're hired back for fall, so you have months to stew. But I found myself worrying less about whether they would not want me back than I was worrying about, oh my God, what if they do want me back? Because I was worried about going to a place that had made me feel so crazy. But on the other hand, nothing felt crazier than the idea of leaving this job that every comedy person wants, that I wanted since I was 10. I started to think about what I would miss, and I thought, oh, I'll miss that approval. I'll miss the approval of the audience laughing and Lorne laughing. But then, I remember that, ironically, the sketch that got me that approval was one that I wrote at a shitty Starbucks by myself before I thought I was worthy of even getting the job.
When I did get the job, I didn't have the glamorous experience that I imagined I would have when I was 10 and I was watching that show on a black-and-white TV. But I actually had a much more important experience, because what I learned was to be brave. SNL taught me that you can't be afraid to just put something out into the world that's yours and to do something that you believe in, and that's totally different. And so, when SNL finally called my agent and they said they wanted me back, I respectfully said no. And that fall, I took my laptop back to Starbucks and I just started to write something new. Thanks.
[cheers and applause]
Jay: [00:47:46] That was Jessi Klein. Jessi is an Emmy and Peabody Award winner for her work as the head writer of Inside Amy Schumer. She's also the author of the New York Times bestselling collection of essays, You'll Grow Out of It.
People always ask us, where we find our stories. We find them at SLAM events all around the country, and you can find out about those at themoth.org. But we also get them from our Pitchline. You can call us up and tell us a short version of your story. Here's the phone number. That’s 877-799-M-O-T-H. 877-799-M-O-T-H. We develop the best pitch searches for Moth shows all around the world.
Elizabeth: [00:48:32] Well, many years ago, I was a single mom and I was working. My son was a latchkey kid and he got in trouble. He was vandalizing the neighborhood in between the time he got home from school and I got home from work. He had damaged some guy's car, the paint on the car. He had scratched some cuss words into it. I heard about it, I learned about it and I was taking my son up the long stairs to this guy's house to have my son confess and ask what we could do to make restitution. My son was telling me, “No, I don't want to go up there.” This is a 10-year-old. And he's saying, “This guy's really big, Mom. You don't know how big he is.”
Well, I had to take him up there, and I kept encouraging him all the way up and saying, “You know, I'm right here with you. He's not going to hurt you, but you need to tell him that you're the one who did this and ask him what we can do.” So, the guy opens the door and he looks at me and he says, “You?” I was shocked and I said, “What?” I said, “My son needs to talk to you.” And he said, “No, you.” He said, “You're the one.” He began to tell me about how he had recently lost his wife, like six months before this, and how I had smiled at him every morning.
He said, “You probably don't even know me. You probably never even realized that you were doing it.” But he said, “Every day we go to work at the same time.” And he said, “I was suicidal, I wanted to kill myself. But I'd get myself up to see your smile, and you kept me alive.” And I thought, wow. I've thought of that story now for 40 years, the way it happened. Even the smallest thing can change a person or help them, give them hope.
Jay: [00:50:50] Remember, you can pitch us your story at themoth.org. At our website, you can buy tickets to storytelling events in your area, find out about SLAMs. There are Moth events year-round. Come on out and tell a story.
That's it for this episode of The Moth Radio Hour. We hope you'll join us next time. And that's the story from The Moth.
[overture music]
The stories in this show were directed by Sarah Austin Jenness and Catherine McCarthy. The rest of The Moth’s directorial staff includes Catherine Burns, Sarah Haberman, Jenifer Hixson and Meg Bowles. Production support from Emily Couch.
Moth stories are true, as remembered and affirmed by the storytellers. Our pitch came from Elizabeth Gillatly. Our theme music is by The Drift. Other music in this hour from Ivan Resendez, Rafiq Bhatia, Blue Dot Sessions, Mark Orton and the Chandler Travis Three-o. You can find links to all the music we use at our website.
The Moth Radio Hour is produced by me, Jay Allison, with Viki Merrick at Atlantic Public Media in Woods Hole, Massachusetts. This hour was produced with funds from the National Endowment for the Arts. The Moth Radio Hour is presented by the Public Radio Exchange, prx.org. For more about our podcast, for information on pitching us your own story and everything else, go to our website, themoth.org.