Host: Suzanne Rust
[overture music]
Suzanne: [00:00:12] From PRX, this is The Moth Radio Hour. I'm your host, Suzanne Rust, The Moth's curatorial producer. Sometimes people ask me what Moth stories are about. I tell them they are really about everything and anything which explains the title of this episode, Punks, Blessings, Burlesque and Lotus Flowers. Like this title, Moth stories are like life itself, a variety show with every act imaginable. But what often unites them are common themes, like self-discovery, finding sanctuary, learning to forgive, and acknowledging blessings of different kinds.
Our first story is from Eddy Laughter, who discovers just what she needs in a most unlikely place. She told this story at our Moth Teacher Institute. Here's Eddy.
[cheers and applause]
Eddy: [00:00:58] I'm on my way to see live music for the first time, and I'm so much more anxious than I think I have any right to be, because this band I'm about to see, I'm completely and utterly obsessed with. I have seen every interview. YouTube will physically let me watch and I listen to them so much at this point, it's probably doing something unhealthy to me. I don't know how that would work, but it's happening. [audience laughter]
Because when I listen to them, all of a sudden, I feel like I'm big and I'm powerful and nothing can touch me when I'm walking down the street, which is really not something I feel ever at this point in my life. I feel so small and clunky and I don't fit into my own body, right? I'm starting to think that the middle school mentality that I'll never fit into any scenario, I go to is just going to be how I live my life and I feel like I just have to accept this at this point.
So, it doesn't make any sense that I'm this anxious to see this band. But I'm trying to think about what I can expect and I'm just thinking about how in movies, punk shows are always like a bunch of loud, aggressive, intoxicated white boys. And that doesn't really seem like my scene. [audience laughter] I'm spiraling a bit, and I'm looking around on the train and I see this girl who's about 9 years or 11 years. I don't know how age works, but she's there and she's with her dad. And I'm like, “Wonder if they're going to the punk show [audience laughter] and then more of a mess.”
I'm still spiraling. And then I get off the train and we get to the venue. It doesn't look like a venue, but it definitely is a venue because I get inside and it's dark and everyone's bigger than me. It's really loud, and I pick a direction, and I just start walking and I see my eighth-grade math teacher [audience laughter]. Because of course, I see my eighth grade math teacher, so I go up and talk to my eighth-grade math teacher, [audience laughter] because that's how he wants to spend his Friday.
I get up to him and it was a lot less awkward than you would think. He asked me about music and what bands I listen to, and I forget every single band I've ever heard of, ever. And I'm like, “This one.” [audience laughter] And thankfully, I'm interrupted by the first band that's up. They introduce themselves and they have this very nice welcoming speech about just accepting everyone who's at the show and I'm like, “Oh, wow.” And then, they start screaming, and they sound like they're wounded animals, [audience laughter] but then there's this weird pop music playing underneath it, and they're still screaming and then after each song ends, the front person goes, “Thank you,” and then continues screaming for the next song, and it's awesome.
And then, this goes on for a bit and it stops, and then I creep out of the corner that I'm in and the next band is up and they again start screaming, of course, as you do. [chuckles] But these guys, they legitimately sound like they're demons. [audience laughter] And just from how they're moving to the way this man's eyes look and whatever the noise is that's coming out of him, and for some reason, I start to relax a bit and people are starting to dance around me in this way, where it feels like there's a big sense of unity in the room. I don't know where that's coming from. [audience laughter] And then, my band [chuckles] has gone up to tune their instruments, and I'm like, “Arghh.” And then, I text my friend and I'm like, “I see the front woman,” and she's like, “Argh” And I'm like, “Argh” this is all over text. [audience laughter]
I'm so excited. I can feel everyone else is just as excited as I am. It feels like the room is buzzing, which is so crazy, because no one's ever excited about what I'm excited about. And then, they start playing, and it's like all of the air and sound gets sucked out of the room. We're all watching them, and we're all just so excited to be there, but it's beyond excitement at this point. It's like, everybody is where I am in my head right now, and we're all just there together and we're all having the same experience.
They start to play more songs. They start to get into the music a little bit more, and everyone else around me is doing that as well, and they start to play my favorite songs and apparently everybody else's favorite songs too. And then, people are starting to dance more. There's this woman in front of me, and all she's doing is jumping up and down, which in any other context would look ridiculous, but it doesn't at all look ridiculous now and like, “I can do that too.” So, I start to move and jump around a bit.
And then, I get that same sense of power and freedom that I get when I listen to it normally, but it's fresher or it was revived or something. And then, someone nudges me and pushes me out of the way and takes my front middle spot. I'm about to get internally offended, because conflict is scary. [audience laughter] But then, I just see that this woman was just making space for her girlfriend to go up next to her and I'm like, “This is a room full of punk, queer women.”
I didn't know that was a thing. I just need a minute to sit and process that. I look around and I see the girl from the train sitting on her dad's shoulders with these big clunky headphones, so her ears don't get all messed up. I would think that it would be weird for a kid to be here, but she looks like she's exactly where she's supposed to be. I start to realize that I feel like I'm exactly where I'm supposed to be too. And so, I just let myself hold onto that. And the last thing I want to do is run away and hide in a corner. I really feel like I belong here. I'm so happy, and I've never felt this happy before.
And then, the band still in a show, and there's a mosh pit that's forming next to me, which I don't go in, because I would get squashed like a little tiny person pancake. But I'm on the side of it and I can still feel all the energy from it. I'm still riding off of that excitement that I'm feeling and that everybody else is feeling, as previously mentioned. And then, eventually the band, they stop playing, and I come back to my body and I really don't want to leave the room, but I realize that I have to. I look at the front woman and I'm like, “Haa”
And then, I leave and get on the subway and I'm looking at all these other people who are at the show with me and I can tell, because they're holding little various bits of merch or whatnot. I'm looking at them and I'm realizing that they're all like me in some way. And in so many different ways, they're like me, which I really didn't think was a thing. I didn't realize that I had something to grow up into before. I don't really know what I thought would happen to me, but I just never had an image that my life could go somewhere and I could stay being the weirdo person I am and have it make sense in the world around me.
I started to realize that the small feeling that I'm holding onto, I don't need it anymore and I never needed it. And that I'm not that small person, and I'm not going to be small forever, and I don't need to be and that I'm going to be okay and it's just so crazy to think about. Thank you.
[cheers and applause]
Suzanne: [00:07:32] That was Eddy Laughter. Eddy is a Brooklynite and a student at Smith College, where she studies different forms of storytelling, as well as what the moon looks like in low light pollution. We're proud to say that Eddy is also one of The Moth's education program alumni teaching interns.
Eddy was just 15 when she attended that concert. And in case you were wondering, the band was a Screaming Females. I had to google them. They are still one of her favorite groups, and listening to them brings her a lot of joy and comfort. Here's a taste of their music.
[Screaming Females band’s song]
To see photos of Eddy on her way to a Screaming Females concert, go to our web extras at themoth.org.
Next up, a Broadway debut of sorts and a hidden talent, when The Moth Radio Hour continues.
[Screaming Females band’s song]
Jay: [00:08:47] The Moth Radio Hour is produced by Atlantic Public Media in Woods Hole, Massachusetts. And presented by PRX.
Suzanne: [00:08:58] This is The Moth Radio Hour from PRX. I'm Suzanne Rust. This next story is about a young man's growing awareness of his sexuality and might not be suitable for everyone. So, if that's you or those around you, please just rejoin us in about seven minutes. I'll spare you from my mediocre singing voice, but you know how the song goes. They say the neon lights are bright on Broadway, they say there's always magic in the air.
Well, our next teller, Christopher Brune-Horan, found even more on Broadway. He told this story at one of our Los Angeles StorySLAMS, which are supported by the public radio station KCRW. Here's Christopher.
[cheers and applause]
Christopher: [00:09:37] The first time that I saw the sign that said the Gaiety Theatre, all male burlesque, I was on a yellow school bus with my Cub Scout troop traveling through lower Manhattan on our way to see the Radio City Rockettes. I must have been 10 years old. All the other boys were singing a very rowdy rendition of our favorite bus song, Ravioli. I love Ravioli. Ravioli, it's the one for me. [audience laughter] And they were super, super excited about the pictures of the Rockettes that they had seen. These long-legged dancers always posed with their legs in a kick line. But here I was looking out the window at West 46th street at this sign that said, all male burlesque.
Now, I didn't know what was going on up that dark stairwell, and I didn't know what the two or three guys were doing who were looking over their shoulder before they went up. But I knew that I wanted to find out. I knew that I liked boys the way that most boys liked girls. As early as first grade, when on a jammed family car trip going somewhere, I was thrown in the backseat on my cousin John's lap and I didn't want to get out of the car. [audience laughter]
In fifth grade, I played my first spin the bottle game. I just was acutely aware that I wanted that bottle to land on either Chip or Billy or Pat. It just kept landing on Bridget over [audience laughter] and over and over. If it did land on two boys, they just spun it again like nobody cared. And it wasn't even an option. [audience laughter] The environment in my small town about gay was hostile, and my body and my voice betrayed me. I strutted where other boys walked, and people were starting to mistake me for my mother when I picked up the phone and said hi. People like my father, who should have known better. [audience laughter]
Junior high was the worst. I mean, it truly got dangerous. People started calling me faggot in the hallway. I was taking shit wherever I went. At the time, my thinking was that if I just became very small and I didn't say anything about it, that maybe it would go away. You know, I might handle that differently today. But then I just thought, if I start fighting with people, I'm going to be bloody every day of my life. And so, around the same time, my best buddy, Agnes and I, we started sneaking down to New York City on the bus. She was an underdog as well.
She was Polish, with the unfortunate last name of Spakowitz, Agnes Spakowitz. And kids were cruel to her as well. We loved the movie, Fame. We loved the Soundtrack. We used to sing it in the streets. We felt so very free in New York City. We would sit on the steps of the School of Performing Arts, pretending to be students. And that was when I saw the Gaiety Theatre again. My heart started to race.
I steered Agnes over by the entrance, carefully noting that shows began on the hour that beginning at 01:00 PM, and later I left her at the New York Public Library, browsing and I ran the four blocks and two avenues it took to get me back there. I was as shady as anybody else going up. I guess nobody goes up proudly. [audience laughter] I threw my shoulders back with this pitiful attempt to look older, but the bored lady taking tickets, she couldn't even be bothered to look at me. It was just one crank of the turnstile, and I was in there.
I was in there and I remember the whole place had this just this feeling of forbidden. It took a while for my eyes to adjust. It was just black. There was men everywhere, ranging in age from 20 to 80, but nobody was looking at anybody. I remember noticing that somebody had cared enough to hang wallpaper, but there were sweat marks on it where the dancers leaned against it to tie their shoes. I was scared. I didn't know what to do. I was frozen. I remember I heard muffled voices, and I knew that there was a movie playing. So, I pushed the lobby doors open. And there, for the first time in my life, in big Technicolor, in huge screen, was gay pornography. I had never seen men having sex before.
Suddenly, the movie stopped and music started to play. The screen went up and there was a black box stage. I realized all male burlesque means strip show. I had no idea, [chuckles] like I was that young. This construction worker walks out on the stage, and somebody says into a microphone, “Gentleman, Dino.” And this Italian guy comes out on the stage, and I realize I'm about to watch a strip show. He literally starts to dance awkwardly, like he was in pain. Nobody moves. We're all as embarrassed as he is. Nobody's catcalling or whistling like they do at women in movies.
And then, suddenly he's done, and he's just down to his underwear and he leaves the stage. I'm sitting there with my testosterone churning, wondering like what's going to happen. And then, he comes back on stage where the slow song starts to play. This time, he's stark naked with nothing but work boots. He just walks around, not even bothering to dance anymore, just displaying himself like a toddler who hasn't been schooled yet or a rooster in a barn guy. [audience laughter]
Anyway, I ended up going back to the Gaiety. The next time, I went back to the Gaiety, I had $60 in my pocket, and I hired a dancer who looked just like Leroy from Fame. I ended up going back there about 10 more times throughout high school. It was my secret that I told no one about. I had my first experience with a guy there in a fire escape, just off the backstage entrance. It wasn't my ideal. [audience laughter]
I remember we locked eyes with having that gaydar radar that we have, and we went back there and he obliged. It was nothing that I was proud of at the time. But I went back there recently with my husband on a trip to New York, and I saw the Gaiety Theatre and it's gone. The marquee is gone. Everything about that error. I told my husband what I did, and I was very proud of that kid who had done that, who had the courage to find sanctuary and survive.
[cheers and applause]
Suzanne: [00:16:16] That was Christopher Brune-Horan. He lives in Los Angeles with his husband and their sons. He's a playwright, essayist and educator who, among other things, developed a storytelling program for inmates at the Men's Central Jail in Los Angeles. It's hard to be different, especially when you're a kid. And Christopher remembers being bullied and feeling isolated. He was afraid of anyone discovering the truth about him. Although his best male friend was also gay and they spoke every day, they didn't share that information with each other until they were in their twenties. He says that the outside messages they got were that scary. Eventually, he found his people in drama club and musicals in high school, but he always felt afraid and self-conscious.
I asked Christopher what advice he'd give to his younger self. And he said, “Tell someone, anyone, shame is the worst. One day, you'll stand in front of 150 people and marry the man of your dreams with your brother as best man and your Irish Catholic father weeping in the front row next to mom. You're a trailblazer and you don't even know it.”
To see photos of Christopher as a child and as a teen one of his undercover trips to New York City, go to themoth.org.
There are times in life when you need to find creative ways to control chaos. Our next story was told by Louise Newton-Keogh at a StorySLAM in Melbourne, Australia, where we partner with the Australian Broadcasting Corporation, ABCRN. Here's Louise.
[cheers and applause]
Louise: [00:17:59] Hi. So, when I was in grade three, I learnt a valuable lesson about controlling the universe from my little sister, Helen, and a pair of dodgy rosary beads. So, there wasn't a lot of control in my life at home at that stage. My mum was living with a mental illness and my dad was a Vietnam vet who tried to manage his PTSD with alcohol. So, there was a lot of chaos, not much control, and certainly not much an eight-year-old could do about it. But when I was in grade three, I thought I'd solve this. I thought I could find a way to control the universe.
You see, grade three is a very special time when you go to a Catholic primary school. It's the year of the first Holy Communion, which basically means you get the bread and the wine, and also means that you get to wear a white dress and eat lots of fairy bird and drink lemonade at the party afterwards. So, it was a fairly big deal. It also means you get your first ever religious education.
So, in our school, religious education, they introduced these two amazing, wonderful storytelling nuns. And these women, if they were alive today, would be on the Moth, for sure. Now, the first nun was called Sister Mary Caulfield. And she liked to tell stories of gloom and doom and what would happen if we sinned. So, she would tell stories that you'd never forget. Like, the boy who went to church and refused to kneel and then when he went outside, he got hit by a bus and broke both legs and had to kneel for the rest of his life. [audience laughter] So, that one stuck with me forever. [audience laughter]
And then, there was Sister Vincent, Sister Mary Vincent, and she was this amazing Oprah-esque woman and honestly, she would not be out of place, as a motivational speaker today. Basically, she said, “The secret to the universe, the way you could [unintelligible [00:19:49] Jesus, is what she called the universe, says just to follow Jesus, to put what you want out to God and He would help you. So, follow Jesus, do what He asked you to do, be good, and Jesus would solve everything.”
So, I thought, oh, cool. So, I'm really good, if I'm really, really good, then Jesus will listen and He will answer my prayers and my mum will be fine and my dad won't drink and this was what I thought I would do. My mission was to be good, the goodest kid that ever was. [audience laughter] And the trouble with that is I didn't actually know how to do that, because I was a pretty good kid anyway. So, I thought there were three things. One was my times tables, which was another big deal in grade three. So, I went out of my way to learn them. I spent every night before I went to sleep reciting from 2 2s to 12 12s and back again.
And the other one was I did the dishes without complaining, even when it was not my turn. Felt really proud. And the other one was not fighting with my brother and sisters. And that was hard, because once they cottoned onto what I was doing, they absolutely went out of their way to make me crack. It's like, “Let's see if we can make the angel crack this time.” So, that was hard. But I persevered. Didn't seem to help, but then came the glory day when it was our feast day and the whole school was given rosary beads, the entire school. And apparently, they were blessed by the Pope himself. So, that was a big deal. [audience laughter]
But these were the dodgiest rosary beads you've ever seen. I'm like, “If I can try pink little beads of plastic held together by flimsy white string and on the end was a silver cross, I want to see if you paid $2 for them, you'd be ripped off.” But in my mind, they were the most beautiful thing I've ever seen in my life. And for me, this was the key to the universe, because I thought, “Ha ha, I've got the rosary beads. Now I know what to do.” So, I became a blesser. [audience laughter]
I didn't actually know what blessing-- I didn't really know what I was doing. So, my way of blessing people would be touch them with the rosary beads and say, “You are blessed.” [audience laughter] And so, what I would do every night before I went to bed, before I set my times table, I would go on house touching my family, my mum, my dad, my brother, my sisters, saying, “You are blessed.” And then, I moved on to my cats, my dog, [audience laughter] then I moved on to my toys, then I moved on to my times table and so on. And I did this every single night.
Now, there were some interesting reactions at home. Dad, who the only thing he loved more than beer was Catholic church, prayed Jesus and thought finally he had one and that I was planning my trip into the convent when I was 15. Mum was a bit bemused, but she thought, oh, well, if it makes me happy and it doesn't seem to be bothering anyone, what the heck? My brother, Patrick, who was a bit older and a bit further along the enlightenment journey, he thought it was hysterical. [audience laughter] And he also used every opportunity he could to tease me. Like, just as I was about to bless him, he locked himself in the bathroom while he's covered and say, “I think I'll be a while.” I say, “But Patrick, I can't bless you before I go to bed. Come on.”
My sister Mary, she really just got angry. Like, “Don't touch me with those things.” So, then I had to become a covert blesser. [audience laughter] What do I do? I would go up to her and I'd just go, tap. Or, when she was brushing her teeth, I'd accidentally bump into her and say, tap, “You are blessed,” [audience laughter] And hope she didn't hit me. My sister, Helen, she became my disciple. She became a blesser. [audience laughter] She was two years younger than me and she followed me, blessing everything behind me. [audience laughter] We were the blessers.
But Helen actually took it one step further than me. She blessed objects. So, she started blessing the wall, the floor, the couch, [audience laughter] the taps. I was really impressed, but I didn't do that. Well, I did bless the odd wall, but only one or two. [audience laughter] But then, of course, this kept going and something had to give, and it did. One night, I had gone through my blessing ritual, was in bed doing my times tables, waiting for Helen to finish hers and turn the lights off when there was a bang, and the lights went out and smoke. We could smell smoke. And there was silence. And then, I heard my mother screaming my sister's name. That's when I realized there was something really, truly wrong.
So, I jumped out of bed, and dad had found a way to turn the lights on. My sister, Helen was on the bed, shaking uncontrollably. And in her hand was a black cross. It turns out, my sister had tried to bless the electricity with a metal cross. Now, she was okay, and dad believed that Jesus had saved her. And Patrick believed that Jesus just wanted to shut us up. [audience laughter] But surely, she was saved by the foam mattress that she was leaning on. But it did have an instantaneous effect. We were cured. That was it. We were done. [audience laughter] The days of controlling the universe with rosary beads were over. Thank you.
[cheers and applause]
Suzanne: [00:24:55] That was Louise Newton-Keogh. She lives in Melbourne with her husband, where she's a student advocate at La Trobe University. While she rarely tells stories these days, she does write daily and calls it her true passion.
Louise is still very close to her four siblings, and they often reminisce about growing up in their tiny house filled with cats, rosary beads and violins. She's pleased to say that her sister, Helen, has shown no ill effects from the electric shock she received so long ago. And during the dark times, Louise says that she will reach for the rosary beads, but only to pray, never to bless. However, she does count her blessings daily.
To see photos of Louise as a child and with her sister, go to the web extras at themoth.org.
In a moment, a story from a woman reconciling her complicated past with her father and his demons, when The Moth Radio Hour continues.
Jay: [00:26:07] The Moth Radio Hour is produced by Atlantic Public Media in Woods Hole, Massachusetts. And presented by PRX.
Suzanne: [00:26:20] You're listening to The Moth Radio Hour from PRX. I'm Suzanne Rust. This next story is about a father-daughter relationship complicated by the horrors of war. Pauline Nguyen told this story in Perth, Australia's Octagon Theatre in 2008. You'll hear that the recording quality back then isn't quite up today's standards, but we think you'll be fine with it. Here's Pauline.
[cheers and applause]
Pauline: [00:26:44] When Saigon fell to communist rule in 1975, my father realized that he had no choice but to escape Vietnam. And the only way that he could do this was to build a boat, and smuggle himself and his family out to sea. I was three years old at the time and my brother, Louis, was two.
My grandmother begged my father not to leave. She couldn't understand how a parent would want to risk perishing their children out at sea. But my father is a very determined man. He stands at just 5’1”, a little shorter than myself, but what he lacks inches he makes up for in fearlessness and determination and he had already made up his mind. He would rather die trying than risk imprisonment or to suffer a fate far worse, the re-education camps. “It's not enough that they take our freedom,” he would tell me. “They want to take our thoughts as well.” My father was determined that, “If we died, we will all die together.”
So, in October 1977, armed with only a rudimentary map and a compass to guide him, my father steered our vessel, our tiny vessel, out into the South China Sea. We spent our days drifting, and waiting and praying. We prayed that a foreign ship might come and save us. We prayed that we might find friendly shores. We prayed that the pirates wouldn't attack us and we prayed that our supplies would not run out. But our prayers were not always answered. Ship after ship after ship ignored our SOS, the most basic code of the sea. And at gunpoint, a group of Malaysian soldiers pushed us off supposedly friendly shores.
We ended up in Thailand, where we spent a very difficult year. And in 1978, Australia finally accepted us. The government housed us at Westbridge Migrant Hostel, and my father quickly found a job working on the production line at the Sunbeam factory in Campsie. Sunbeam gave him the graveyard shift from 02:00 PM to 02:00 AM, and they gave him all the jobs that nobody wanted. “The train ride home was the worst,” my father would later tell me. Every night was dangerous for him.
The locals threatened to beat him and the bigots threatened to kill him. My father cried every day going home on that train. A lot of us cried in those days. We came into this new world with nothing. Nothing. No job, no house, no money. We didn't know the laws, the systems or the language. My father had nightmares. And it's the same dream over and over. He's back in Vietnam. He's preparing for our escape. He's back in the water, drifting day after day with nowhere to go and then he wakes up.
My father had constant flashbacks to the war. Part of his job as a lieutenant in artillery was to return to the scene and count the dead bodies after a kill. One shell killed so many. The scars from his own bullet wounds resemble a question mark down the length of his spine. But determined to succeed, my father took on a second job, and then a third job and then a fourth job. And at home, he was always angry. He had anger in him that none of us could explain. He would throw things, he would yell at us, he would smash things. And sometimes he would just stand there and scream.
My father was determined to raise four high achievers. He wanted to make sure that the sacrifices that he and my mother made were honored. It wasn't long until he started offloading his anger upon my mother. Soon after that, he started to offload his anger upon his children as well. If someone were to ask me now, “What it is that I remember most about my childhood?” It would be the overwhelming stench of fear. Fear followed us every day of our lives. Fear stayed with me everywhere. My father kept three instruments of torture. The first was a flexible cane whip, the second was a stiff and shiny billiard stick and the third was fear.
Twice a year, from the age of 7 to 13, we would bring our school her reports with absolute fear and loathing. For every B, he caned us once. For every C, he caned us twice. And this ritual required us to lay flat on our stomachs and not budge a millimeter until he was finished. Blow after blow, hacking at the flesh of our buttocks and our thighs. When he was done, he threw us a dollar for every A. My father would find any reason to beat us. And sometimes he would beat us for no reason at all. One of his most well used and memorable quotes, “I created you and I have the power to destroy you.” Yup, he did that all right.
At 17, I ran away from home and I spent many years hiding from my father. I would look over my shoulder everywhere that I went, paranoid that familiar faces were following me. You see, I wanted my fears forgotten, not faced up to. But there comes a time in your life where you need to overcome your fears by looking at it in the face. And for the sake of my mother and for the sake of my brothers and for all the shame that I had dumped upon my family in the years that I was gone, I reluctantly reconciled with my father.
Out of duty, I would go home to visit. And I hated those visits. I hated the sense of claustrophobia and the sense of suffocation that I always felt in his presence. The meetings were always so stifled, and false and tense. But what I hated the most was the overwhelming realization that I had grown up to be just like him. I too was angry all the time. Angry at my loved ones, angry at my work colleagues, angry at the world, angry at myself. Angry people are very skilled at noticing all that is wrong.
I carried this anger for many years. And later, when my partner and I wanted to have a child, I was determined that this cycle end there. I was determined to not be the same person I had always been, because I was frightened. Frightened of history repeating. Frightened of treating my own child the way I had been treated and I needed the cycle to end there. I could not pass on my anger to the next generation.
Toward the end of my pregnancy, I landed a book deal to write a memoir about my family. And as I'm writing this book, my fears returned. As I'm writing this book, I'm thinking, how am I possibly going to survive my father's reaction to this story? There are 10 chapters all up in my book, and it's not meant to be a scathing account about my father. It is a beautiful story about personal freedom, and family and hope. But in order to talk about the good things, I have to talk about the bad things as well.
It was my plan to finish my book and give it to my father in its entirety, so that he could see the full arc of the story and so that he could see what a beautiful story it really is. But as I'm writing this book, this cloud of dread is hanging over me, I know that one day it's going to be published, and I know that one day the world's going to read it and I'm just dreading the day my father's going to read it. But there's a job to be done and a story that needs to be told. And so, I write.
By the end of the seventh chapter, my father demands to read my story. And I freak out. I freak out, because he can't read it now. It's not finished. The seventh chapter is actually the most confronting chapter and it was the most difficult chapter for me to write. It possibly is the most scathing chapter about my father, and he can't possibly read it now. But you don't say no to my father. I had no choice, but to hand over my unfinished manuscript, the story about his life written by his prodigal daughter. I didn't hear from my father for two months, and I needed to hear from my father. I needed to find some sort of closure, so that I can finish my book and move on.
Father's Day came, and I decided to go home and face the music. So, I'm in my car with my beautiful baby daughter, Mia, and we're driving home to bony rig to confront my parents. I am so nervous and so scared with this confrontation that I can hardly breathe. I'm not scared that he's going to hit me or be violent or anything like that. We've passed that stage in our lives. I'm scared, because I've exposed him to the world. I've exposed our family's story to the world and our family secrets. I'm scared, because he might give me some ridiculous ultimatum like, “I forbid you to publish this book” or something crazy like that.
But I'm scared, because I'm about to do something that's never been done before. I'm about to take responsibility to end this family's pattern. I'm about to confront my father in order to make things better than before. And so, Mia and I are waiting at the front door. I've taken with me a case of my father's favorite red wine as a peace offering. When the doors open, they take Mia, they kiss her, they cuddle her. They're so happy to see her. And I see that they've made a feast for me.
We sit down to eat and I ask my father, “Dad, what do you think about my story?” He says, “Good. Good, good, but there's just one thing.” “What's that one thing, dad?” “The fish sauce recipe's wrong.” [audience laughter] “What do you mean the fish sauce recipe is wrong?” “There's no water involved, no water involved.” And I'm thinking, oh my God, this can't be happening.
And later on, I ask him again, “Dad, what do you think about my book?” I get the same response about the fish sauce recipe. I'm so frustrated, we're never going to define our relationship, we're never going to connect. I'm doomed. I'm never going to finish my book. I won't be able to move on. I get my baby ready. I'm getting my things ready and I'm just about to leave and I ask him one last time, “Dad, what do you think about my book?”
And in a voice so sad and serious, he says, “Do you know why Buddha sits on a lotus flower?” “No, dad.” “Why does Buddha sit on a lotus flower?” “There is nothing as beautiful as a lotus flower.” “Out of watery chaos, it grows, emerging from the depths of a muddy swamp and yet remains so pure and unpolluted by it. So pure you can eat it, all of it. The roots, the stems, the leaves, the seeds, the petals. But the lotus flower has another characteristic. Its stem you can easily bend, but you cannot easily break. It has tenacious fibers that hold the plant together. My children are lotus flowers. You have grown out of the aftermath of war. You have grown up in Cabramatta during its murkiest time and you have grown out of me. I am mud. I am dead. I am shit. I am very lucky to have you all.”
And with those words, my father gave me everything that I had been waiting over 20 years for. He never gave me an apology. He gave me acknowledgement. Acknowledgment of the harm that he had inflicted. If someone were to ask me now, what things I think about when I think of my father? I would say I think about forgiveness, I think of redemption and I think about hope. But most of all, I think about unfailing courage in the face of any adversity.
[cheers and applause]
Suzanne: [00:42:12] That was Pauline Nguyen. Pauline is an award-winning author, speaker, entrepreneur and the co-founder of the renowned Vietnamese restaurant, Red Lantern in Sydney, Australia. Her book, Secrets of the Red Lantern: Stories and Vietnamese Recipes from the Heart, is about her family's journey from their native Vietnam to Australia.
[whimsical music]
Our final story was told by Denise Bledsoe Slaughter at a StorySLAM in Washington, D.C., where we partner with public radio station WAMU. Here's Denise.
[cheers and applause]
Denise: [00:42:59] Okay. First of all, I want to say that I'm going to strangle my friend, JR, who talked me into doing this. [audience laughter]
[cheers and applause]
So, you all support murder. [audience laughter] Thank you. I am 66 years old.
[cheers and applause]
I went to grad school at Brown University.
[cheers and applause]
This is a brief story about Pearl Wolf, one of my two mothers. Everybody should have a black mother and a Jewish mother. [audience laughter] Okay, I have been privileged to have had both. [audience laughter] And Pearl was my Jewish mother at Brown for six years. And my last year of grad school, I had custody of my younger brother, who I might note, I still have custody of [audience laughter] 45 years later. You do the math. [laughs] He's gotten worse with age. But really, he was in the ninth grade. I took custody of him. My brother's gay. He and his father, my stepfather, were not getting along. I told my mother, “I'll take him to school with me for a couple of weeks.” It turned into the whole year.
And Providence weather is not that bad, but it can get cold in the winter. And it did. It changed the trajectory of my life in many ways. One of those was that I had to work. And the money that I made was not enough for that first oil delivery. So, we were cold. I called for family members around the country. We were not poverty stricken, but it wasn't a whole lot of extra money. I called my older sister. “Oh, wow, I wish you had called me a couple of weeks ago. I just got back from Nassau. I don't have any money to spare.” I called my mother's famous sister, Velma, [audience laughter] whose husband's name was Jacq, actually was Jack [audience laughter] when I first met him.
And as soon as I mentioned money, she says, “Oh, you need to speak to Jacq.” [audience laughter] Jacq, of course, says, “We don't have any money.” I knew it was a lie. I needed $180, which today doesn't sound like a lot, but what's this, 1976, that was a lot of money. So, I'm whining to Pearl, with whom I work. And Pearl, you got to imagine, is this short, squat woman. You know, she looked like she was a bodybuilder in her youth or something. She had a cigarette permanently glued to the inside [audience laughter] of her lip. She could talk with it like Susan Hayward in the movies. [audience laughter] And so, she says, “What do you need?” I said, “$180.” She said, “Come by the house tonight. I'll give it to you.” I said, “Pearl, I don't know when I'll be able to pay it back.” And she said, “That's okay. That’s okay”
And so, she loaned me that money and it got us through the winter. And the point of my story, is that at the end of that year, I told her I would pay her back. I still didn't have $180. She said, “You got a little refrigerator, right?” And I said, “Yeah, I do,” as a matter of fact. “What are you going to do with it?” And this was the end of my grad school years, I said, “I don't know.” I said, “You want it?” She had three children lined up to go to Brown. So, she said, “I'll take the refrigerator.” So, that was my introduction to bartering. I paid off my debt to Pearl in any number of ways.
And just as a footnote to my story, my brother who went on to become a soldier, so thank you for your service, I thank him for his, he also was diagnosed with HIV in 1983 and he's still alive. He survived all these years.
[applause]
Oh, no. No, that would be too simple. [audience laughter] He became a crack addict and an alcoholic, and that is what you should be applauding. He survived that. He finished his undergraduate years and just got his master's in rehab counseling.
[cheers and applause]
So, I thank Pearl Wolf for keeping us warm.
[cheers and applause]
Suzanne: [00:48:08] Denise Bledsoe Slaughter is a self-described workaholic who looks forward to resting when she retires. But for now, she's a special assistant at the University of the District of Columbia. She also works with a nonprofit that provides education and career skills to low-income residents in the D.C. metro area. She says that helping people realize their ambitions is what keeps her going.
I followed up with Denise to see how she was doing these days. She joked that except for the vagaries of aging, she's doing just fine. And while her brother still has his struggles, she is proud of his accomplishments and is still there for him 100%.
To see a poem that Denise wrote about Pearl but never got to deliver, go to themoth.org. Pearl is no longer with us, but all these years later, Denise says that she is forever grateful for the friendship, tough love and guidance she provided and the belly laughs that they shared. And I heartily agree with Denise, everyone should have a black mother and a Jewish mother. I was so lucky to have had the amazing Edna Rust as my mother and fortunate to have a few Jewish mothers of my own. Sarah B. and Susie S, thanks for being there.
Well, that's it for this episode of The Moth Radio Hour. We hope you'll join us next time. And that's the story from The Moth.
[overture music]
Jay: [00:49:43] This episode of The Moth Radio Hour was produced by me, Jay Allison, Catherine Burns and Suzanne Rust, who also hosted the show. Coproducer is Vicki Merrick. Associate producer, Emily Couch. The stories were directed by Lea Thau with additional education program coaching by Melissa Brown.
The rest of The Moth's leadership team includes Sarah Haberman, Sarah Austin Jenness, Jenifer Hixson, Meg Bowles, Kate Tellers, Jennifer Birmingham, Marina Klutse, Brandon Grant, Inga Glodowski, Sarah Jane Johnson and Aldi Kaza.
The Moth Teachers Institute is made possible by generous support from Alice Gottesman. Thanks also to the Perth International Arts Festival. Moth stories are true, as remembered and affirmed by the storytellers.
Our theme music is by the Drift. Other music in this hour from Screaming Females, Chill, Blue Dot Sessions, Phan Dinh Tung and the Fearless Flyers. We receive funding from the National Endowment for the Arts.
The Moth Radio Hour is produced by Atlantic Public Media in Woods Hole, Massachusetts. And presented by PRX. For more about our podcast, for information on pitching us your own story and everything else, go to our website, themoth.org.