Host: Sarah Austin Jenness
[overture music]
Sarah: [00:00:13] This is The Moth Radio Hour. I'm Sarah Austin Jenness. My mother used to say nothing good happens after midnight. But is that really true? Is that something all parents say to inspire you to get home before curfew? When some folks are getting ready to end their day, others are just getting started. In this episode, stories that all take place late, late at night.
We start with the story of a high school sophomore who attempts to surprise a fellow student he has a crush on. And the attempt lasts all night long. Gary Daniel shared this with us as part of a showcase with The Moth's High School Program. Here's Gary, live at The Moth.
[cheers and applause]
Gary: [00:00:55] So, love. Love is so beautiful, but it can get you killed. So, I'm about to do the craziest thing I have ever done in my life. It was to see a girl that I like that I met in 9th grade, when she was in 10th grade, and now I'm a senior, she already graduated and I don't see her anymore, so I want to see her. So, I decided to go to New Jersey to-- Even though I didn't know the address, I decided to surprise her. Yeah, that was not the smartest idea. [audience laughter] So, I had to go to the terminal bus. I didn't take any charger, my GPS was on the whole time, and I was listening to music and my phone was just dying. So, I got to the terminal bus.
The terminal bus, it was so big that for me, it looks like an airport with hundreds of buses to take. I was so lost that I had to ask somebody, “Yo, I want to get to New Jersey. What should I do?” [audience laughter] And he was like, “Yo, what part of New Jersey you want to go? And I was like, “I just told you, I want to go to New Jersey.” [audience laughter] And his face was like, “Damn, this guy is really lost.” [audience laughter] So, I have to give him my phone with the address, because I didn't even know how to pronounce the place that I was going, and I still don't know how to pronounce it. [audience laughter] He took me to the right place, the right bus. I didn't even know that I had to pay for a bus. I was just depending on my school Metro card. [audience laughter]
[applause]
So, I was lucky. I was lucky that the day before, I asked my mom for money to get a haircut, which I never did. Sorry, mom. [audience laughter] But that was good, because I used the money to get into the bus. So, when I got to the line, I realized that line was bigger than the Washington Bridge. Like, I spent an hour in that line. When I finally got to the bus and there was only one seat left and a woman next to it. She was just looking at me, like, saying, “Don't even think about sitting next to me.” [audience laughter] We started talking about telepathy, and I was like, “I don't care. I'm going to sit there because I've been waiting for an hour and I'm tired. I'm going to sit there.”
I sit in there, and my GPS stopped working, and this woman was looking at me the whole time and I just was in panic. So, I thought the bus was already past the place that I wanted to go. I got off earlier. And my GPS, for some reason, started working again and I realized that I was two hours away from her house. I was just lost. [audience laughter] I realized that love is really blind, because it makes you do things that you never thought you would do. Crazy things. I was able to see the whole New York City, and I was like, “Damn, this is beautiful. But it will be more beautiful if I could see her instead.”
I took that moment to tell myself what the hell I just did. [audience laughter] I just keep walking and walking. I was so hungry that I heard my stomach saying like, (in a different voice) “Feed me, please. Man, you're going to die if you don't feed me.” So, my phone was 1%. It was like one minute before it dies and I die with it. [audience laughter] I took the last minutes just to call her and at least hear her voice. It was like my last words. [audience laughter] And I told her, I patiently said, “Yo, I lost. Please help me.” It was just at that moment that my phone died. So, I was just sitting in front of a building, hoping that somebody would help me. The people were just walking by me, like they didn't care. There was even one guy that gave me $1. I appreciate it. At least something. [audience laughter]
So, it started raining, and I said, I'm going to a building, somebody's building, even though that I can get arrested. I don't care, I got to find a place to sleep, dude. So, I went to the last floor. It was not as good as my bed, but it was something at least. And next day, I woke up and I was totally a mess. I had a headache, my back was hurting and I told myself, is this really how I want to surprise her? [audience laughter] So, I went to a store, so that I can get a charger or something. There were some Dominicans from my country, and they were like, “Yo, que lo que mano Toko Dutad.” [audience laughter] That means how are you? [audience laughter] And I told him, “Yo, I'm lost in another state. I was sleeping in the stairs, but I'm good. I'm happy to be alive at least.” [audience laughter]
So, once my phone finally got GPS was on and I realized that I was literally next to her house. I don't know how I get there, but I was next to her house. I called her and I told her, “I'm here. Can you please pick me up, because I don't know where I am. All I know is that I'm around your house.” And she was like, “I'm sick. I can't.” And I told her, “So, you're telling me that I came all the way to New Jersey to see you, you're telling me that you're sick.” Obviously, she thought it was a joke. And I told her, “Can you please see through the window if I can find you?” She saw me, and she was shaking her hand. It was the best one for me. I was like, “I finally got it.” And she told me, “Yes, you're really crazy.” [audience laughter]
So, I went to her house. We ate some papas con salami. She gave me some chocolate, because I was really cold. Although she's not here, I just want to thank her, because she accepted to go to prom with me and-- [audience go aww]
[cheers and applause]
Wait, I'm not done. [audience laughter] So, I don't know what they always think I've done when I say that. [audience laughter] So, since this is being recorded, I just want to tell you that you're the most beautiful girl I ever met. And even though you might not feel the same for me, I just want to let you know that I love you.
[cheers and applause]
Sarah: [00:09:39] That was Gary Daniel. Gary lives in the Bronx, and he says he spent the past year meditating, studying martial arts and reading a lot. He's also excited to tell more stories now that we can get back out in the world again.
I asked Gary, what advice would you give to people out there who want to surprise their crushes? And he said, “Do not risk your life to impress someone. It's not necessary. Instead, muster the courage to tell them how you feel directly. If they reject you, the right person will come at the right moment.” By the way, Gary and his crush did go to the prom, so his elaborate stunt worked. And to see their sweet prom photo, go to our website, themoth.org.
Up next is Otis Gray, with a story that takes place one night in a restaurant just outside of Providence, Rhode Island. Here's Otis, live at The Moth.
[cheers and applause]
Otis: [00:10:40] I have a degree in sculpture from Rhode Island School of Design. So, naturally, I now have seven years’ experience waiting tables. [audience laughter] I actually love serving tables. Like, I love giving people an exquisite dining experience. And food has always been a really big thing for me. You can actually make a ton of money as a server if you have the right job. But there's a catch. All of your money comes completely from tips, which means you have to be intelligent, you need to be efficient, you have to seem happy. [audience laughter] When shit hits the fan, because it always does, you have to apologize, you have to say, “I'm sorry. Is there anything I can do for you?” The stuff that you have to deal with as a server is absolutely ridiculous.
One time during a busy service, I had a woman pay for a $35 meal completely in change. I had one dude who ate a four-course meal alone and refused to pay, because the restaurant was just a little too hot. I had a table try to set me up on an actual arranged marriage with their daughter who was there. [audience laughter] You deal with this shit all the time, but all you can do is smile and nod, because you need the job, you need to get paid. But I went to art school, so I had this problem with authority, I guess. [audience laughter]
So, when I was in senior of college, Providence, Rhode Island, I got this really great job at a high-end Italian restaurant. Killer food, really, really good staff. I was walking out with like over $200 in my pocket every night. They had this rule where if a table didn't finish their bottle of wine, you could cork it and take it home. Great rule. [audience laughter] It was awesome. But there's still you have this job where every night, it feels like you're dying a little bit. [audience laughter]
So, one night, we're working in the restaurant and I am deep in the weeds. Basically, that means that shit has hit the fan. There is, you cannot make all of your tables happy. It is a triage situation. It is absolute chaos. It's like I'm running around, it's halfway through the night and out of the corner of my eye, I see this woman come in the door. I know this woman is going to steer this ship into the iceberg. [audience laughter] I see this woman and she is so visibly intoxicated, like she just reeks 20 feet away. She's with two really stylish gay gentlemen that are walking in with her and she stumbles over the table, barely makes it there. She flops down in the seat and I'm like, “All right, I'm going to deal with this.”
So, I run up and I say, “How are you, folks? My name is Otis. I'll be your server tonight.” These two dudes are very visibly judging me, because even though I was wearing my uniform, I guess they could tell I was a slob on the inside. [audience laughter] This woman's like, “Listen, Oscar. [audience laughter] We want bread and olives, and we want you to come right back.” I'm like, “All right, I'm Oscar. Okay.” So, I go get the bread and the olives, and I bring it back, and I'm running around the restaurant and I'm going by her table, and she grabs my arm, which you don't do. And I'm like, “I'm sorry, miss. How can I help you?” She's like, “I want to order.” I'm like, “Fantastic. I'll be right with you.”
I'm running around, because table five needs two packets of Splenda, and table nine kids spilled chocolate milk all over his dad's steak. He's pissed. This woman starts yelling across the entire restaurant, “Oscar.” [audience laughter] Everyone's so furious at me and her and the whole thing. So, I'm running over, I'm like, “Yes, miss, how can I help you?” She's like, “Listen Oscar, I want this Pinot Grigio because it's from my favorite region, but I don't want to taste any peaches.” I'm like, “All right, miss. This particular Pinot Grigio does have notes of peaches in it.” Like it says right on the menu. “I want this Pinot Grigio, but that better not taste any peaches.” [audience laughter]
And I go and I put the Pinot in, and it comes to her table, and I'm running by again, and she grabs my arm again and she shoves the glass of wine into my face, pours the wine on my uniform. “Smell this. What do you smell?” “Peaches. Peaches.” “I said I didn't want any peaches, Oscar.” Dudes are loving this. They are dying. And the whole restaurant is in flames. I know that this woman isn't even going to tip me. I'm not going to even-- I don't benefit at all from this. I know I should, I should apologize and say sorry and walk away, but I snapped and I thought, I'm going to sell this woman the most expensive bottle of wine on the goddamn menu. [audience laughter] The Bodega Noemia Malbec, which is a $450 bottle of wine, because I know these two dudes aren't drinking. And if she has another sip, she's going to have to get her stomach pumped. I am not usually good at selling wine, but for peaches lady, the shit was on. [audience laughter]
So, I said, “Miss, if you didn't like that Pinot Grigio, I think I have something that you'll really enjoy.” It was a masterpiece. It was like a ballet. [audience laughter] I was like, “Miss, this Malbec has notes of mocha and dark plum and you can feel the smoke. And the vines were coddled from a young age by a man named Raphael who sung the grapes to sleep every night. [audience laughter] And since you know your region so well, you'll know that the soil in the Rio Negro Valley is exquisite.”
These dudes did not see this coming. She is entranced. And I said, “Miss, this Malbec is simply an experience. [audience laughter] And you seem like the kind of person who knows that life is too short to let these experiences [audience laughter] pass you by.” Will take one bottle of the Malbec Oscar.” Bottle comes to her table. We open it up, and she has a sip and she passes out on the table. [audience laughter] Her fine gentleman put her arms over their shoulders and they drag her out the front door. 02:30 AM that night, I leave the restaurant. I made no money. I was exhausted. But I did walk the beautiful streets of Providence, Rhode Island, sipping Bodega [audience laughter] Noemia Malbec straight from the bottle.
[cheers and applause]
Sarah: [00:17:52] That was Otis Gray. Otis told me, “You can tell a lot about people by how they treat restaurant servers. I treat waiters differently ever since I've been one. These days, if I have the luxury of being at a restaurant, I definitely tip extra.” Otis hosts a podcast called Sleepy, where he reads old books in a soothing voice to help you fall asleep, because all late nights have to end at some point.
After our break, two more late night stories, one risky, one risqué. Both take place in New York, the city that never sleeps, when The Moth Radio Hour continues.
Jay: [00:18:38] The Moth Radio Hour is produced by Atlantic Public Media in Woods Hole, Massachusetts.
Sarah: [00:18:47] This is The Moth Radio Hour. I'm Sarah Austin Jenness. The stories in this hour are all about nocturnal adventures. Sometimes when the sun sets, the fun begins.
In 2006, during The Moth's very first US Mainstage tour, my friend and Moth colleague, Gitte and I took a night off while we were in Seattle to have dinner on Bainbridge Island, just off the coast. We took an early evening ferry out to the island. We set our phone alarms before the very last ferry of the night was to leave. Well, Gitte and I had a lot to catch up on and we were laughing and telling stories and you know what happens next. We didn't hear the alarm, but we did hear the sound of the ferry horn. We dumped cash on the counter and we went running through the dark Bainbridge Island woods. We got to the ferry terminal in time to see the boat leaving.
There was one man in the terminal and I said, “Sir, we missed the boat.” And he said, “Well, all the locals are singing karaoke across the street.” So, that's what we did. We went across the street, we sang I got you babe with the rest of the tiny island neighborhood and killed four hours until the ferry started running again. We were exhausted at The Moth the next day, but boy, that was a fun mistake to make. And yes, there's photographic evidence of all of this at themoth.org.
Molly Kendall told our next story at a Moth SLAM in New York, where public radio station WNYC is a media partner. Here's Molly, live at The Moth.
[cheers and applause]
Molly: [00:20:27] About 12 years ago, I moved to New York City. And to this day, I do not know why I did that. [audience laughter] But it was an adventure. And to support my adventure, I had to work two, three, however many jobs, running here to there, trying to find my feet on this pulsing, frenetic city. Within the beginning of the time that I was here, I met this man named John. Being a product of someone who was born and raised here, he had a very calm spirit within this craziness that I felt. So, he and I started to see each other. One winter night, he invited me over. Of course, I'm going to go.
And so, I opened my closet of really tired old looking clothes, and I think with this blast of courage and insanity, screw it, I'm not going to wear any of these. I'm just going to wear my snow boots. It's the middle of winter. My snow boots. I grabbed my Old Navy all weather camel colored trench coat. [audience laughter] I threw that on and--- [audience laughter] yes, every man's dream. I jumped on the M14D bus [audience laughter] and it was empty. I realized looking at this empty bus full of empty seats, I cannot sit down. The coat isn't long enough. I'm just going to hold this pole and hope that this trip goes really quickly.
So, I get to his house, and he buzzes me up, and I go up and I'm thinking like on the bus I had lost all of my courage and [audience laughter] I thought like, what am I doing? What am I doing? I am not this kind of person. [audience laughter] Whatever that means, this is not who I am. I get to his apartment, and I open his door and he's fully clothed, winter jacket on, and he's lacing up his boots and he's like, “You know what? I'm so hungry. Let's go out to dinner.” [audience laughter] And I said, “No, I'm not hungry.” And he said, “Okay, just pizza.” And I was like, “I hate pizza. No.” And he said, “Sushi.” And I was like, “Nope, I don't--" I just couldn't tell him what I had done, because I didn't know what I had done. [audience laughter]
He's like, “All right, you know what? Bruno.” This bartender at the steakhouse where we often went to, he's like, “Bruno's at the bar at Strip House. We're just going to go there. Don't worry about it. We're going to have lamb chops.” He knew the secret to my heart was lamb chops and he said, “Let's go there.” And I thought, oh, my God, every time I say no, it gets worse. Like, pizza to sushi to steak. Like, now it's going to be forever and I'm naked. [audience laughter] “Okay, let's go. Let's just go.”
And so, we go to Strip House, and, like, it's middle of winter, so the beautiful, lovely, sweet coat check lady is like, “Oh, can I take your coat?” And I was like, “No.” [audience laughter] Okay. So, we go. Bruno sees us at the bar and he's like, “Oh, John. Molly. Hey, come on, sit down here. I have your places for you. Molly, take off that stupid coat. It looks like you're ready to run away.” And I was like, “Oh, my God, if you only knew.” [audience laughter] I thought before sitting, like, this is my chance. This is my chance. I'm just going to tell him and we're going to go. Like, I have to get this over with. But I couldn't because I was just too embarrassed. Like, what have I done? And so, we sat down.
Bruno said, “What would you like to drink?” And I was like, “What would get me drunk the fastest?” So, I have the courage to tell him, and I said, “A martini.” Boom. He makes a martini. It's down, gone. And then, he's like, “Wow, okay. Would you like something else?” “Yeah, just another martini. Another martini. I need to think. I need to think.” [audience laughter] He makes the martini and the haze of somewhere else. I hear John ordering three or four courses of something or something. There's a seafood tower involved and [audience laughter] lamb chops and truffled creamed spinach and amazingness. But I was just trying to think like, “How do I get out of this? How do I tell him?” I can't get my courage back. The courage that told me like, “Just go naked.” Like, that courage was gone. [audience laughter]
And so, Bruno's like, “No, seriously, take off your jacket.” And I was like, “You know what? I caught a chill outside. It's cool. I'm fine.” And then, to help me, Bruno decided to turn up the heat in the bar. “Oh, my God, no. Seriously?” Okay. So, he turned up the heat of the bar. I'm sitting at the bar, there's sweat dripping down my face, down into my Old Navy camel colored all weather trench coat. I just didn't know what to do. And the lamb chops come out and I want the lamb chops. I still don't have the courage to say it. And finally, John's like, “Do you want to start with steak or lamb? And I was like, “You're talking about steak. And I'm naked. I'm naked. The polyester is now sticking to my body. [audience laughter] We have to get out of here because I'm naked.” [audience laughter]
He looked at me and, he was like “We had to wrap it up.” [audience laughter] Okay, I know I'm over time, but I have to tell you guys that was 11, 12 years ago, whatever. Present day, we now have a three-and-a-half-year-old daughter. I look at her, and she's like this demon, from the moment that she was born, she's this [audience laughter] tornado in a tiny little thing. I look at her and I think like, “How do I help mold you into the person you're supposed to be?” I realized that when I was seen like I am not this person that we don't have control over who we are and what we're supposed to be. And least of all, we don't have control over our kids, but we can be more than we ever imagined. Thanks.
[cheers and applause]
Sarah: [00:26:49] That was Molly Kendall. Molly lives in New York City with her daughter and their dog, Auggie. Before the pandemic, she was taking flying lessons. But during the pandemic, she's learned to wire crochet and the art of defrosting a freezer. She said, this was her first and last of her intentional naked surprises. And for anyone listening who's considering a stunt like this, Molly says, “Spring for a cab.”
This infamous night took place at a restaurant appropriately named Strip House in Greenwich Village. And to see a photo of Molly with her daughter at the same restaurant, at the same bar many years later, go to themoth.org.
Devin Elise Wilson told this next story outside at the beautiful Greenwood Cemetery in Brooklyn. It was our first in person, socially distanced show after the pandemic hit. And even though the audience was made up of only 20 folks, the living audience that is, we are all so thrilled to have a night out together. You can't do a late-night show without mentioning sex. So, just so you know, sex will be mentioned in this story. Here's Devin, live at The Moth.
[applause]
Devin: [00:28:12] New York City, New Year's Eve. 2020 is going to be a great year. [audience laughter] With my hype song out tonight from Rent, on blast, repeat, I get all jazzed up. I do my makeup, my nails. I lotion my entire body and not just the parts visible to the world. I put on a new dress that hugs me in all the right places, and I throw on a big fluffy coat that makes me feel like a movie star. I grab a couple of condoms and put them in my bag, because you never know. And a lady should always be prepared, especially when she feels this good.
Just as I'm leaving the apartment, I get a text message. It's from my dad. It says, “Hey kiddo, there's a saying that some people use, I don't really like it.” Here goes. “The best way to get over a man is to get under a new one. That's BS. I know you know that. Enjoy your special evening.” [audience laughter] Now, let's backtrack for a minute here. My boyfriend of four months and I had just broken up the day before. We made plans months ago to spend New Year's Eve together in the city at his place, but by the time the holiday came around, we both knew what was coming. There was no spark, and quite honestly, my gut had been trying to tell me for the entirety of the relationship that this just wasn't it. He didn't actually see me.
So, I was glad for the clean break while simultaneously sad to be alone in the city on New Year’s. When I realized I could ring it in from my happy place, Marie's Crisis, I knew I was ready for a fresh start. But how could my dad sense my energy from across the country though? I laughed to myself as me, and my Happy New Year headband and my condoms left the house. Marie's Crisis is a musical theater sing along show tune piano bar in the West Village, and there is no place like it. It's easy to make friends when you're all singing, Defying gravity, Circle of life and Seasons of Love at the top of your lungs. There was one woman in particular who I'd seen there before, she had the voice of a Broadway star. After singing a few songs with each other, she pulled me into her group and we all sang and drank together.
A couple hours in, they started talking about kisses at midnight. She turned to me and said, she was kissing a couple other people, but she'd like to kiss me too. I'd never kissed a woman before. I'd always been open to it, but the opportunity had never presented itself so organically. So, midnight comes around. Five, four, three, two, one. Happy New Year. No kiss for Devin. 12:05, still no kiss. She's busy celebrating with her friends, and I'm not the type to tap her on the shoulder like, “Hi, remember me?”
So, after some high fives and Happy New Year wishes with the random musical theater lovers around me, I slightly disappointed, just keep singing. About 12:15, she turns to me and we lock eyes. I don't think either of us were expecting that kind of kiss. Fireworks. She pulled back and said, “Ooh, this might be my favorite kiss of the night. Don't tell the others.” I didn't, but they might have guessed, because what we did do was continue to make out shamelessly. At a certain point, she leans in and whispers, “Do you want to come home with me?” I say, “Yes,” followed by, “I've never been with a woman before.” She says, “It's okay. I have.” And we keep singing and kissing.
She would pop in and out for a smoke break here and there. When she'd come back in, she'd check, “You're still coming home with me, yeah?” I was getting increasingly more nervous, but not because this would be my first time. So, on her next break, I thought, okay, let's tell her that we're herpes positive now, so that she can make a decision sooner rather than later. So, with resolve, I throw my coat over my shoulders and I walk outside. I was expecting to catch her smoking alone, but she was in a group of at least five people and all I heard was, “You guys. She said it like 10 times. She's definitely coming home with me.” I froze like a deer in headlights. I definitely wasn't supposed to be hearing this.
I pivoted on the balls of my feet to avoid the click clack of my heeled boots on the pavement as I tiptoed back into the bar. They were talking about me. I guess they thought I wasn't going to go through with it. Little did they know me not going through with it was furthest from my mind. Last call. Final song. We hop in a cab, and I am multitasking, enthralled by the feeling of her lips on mine while simultaneously trying to build up the courage. “You can do it. Just say it.” We're on the west side highway now, about 150 blocks from her place, 100 from mine. “Okay, just say it before we pass your place, so if she changes her mind, we can make two stops.”
I allow myself to sink into the unbridled pleasure of us for a few more blocks. Just as I'm coming to the peak of my internal pep talk, she turns to me and says, “I should have said something sooner--" But my heart is racing. “Are you allergic to cats?” [chuckles] I respond, “No,” with a giggle and she laughs too.” She has unknowingly given me the perfect in. I take a breath and say, “Speaking of things we should have mentioned sooner.” And I tell her. I tell her that I'm herpes positive and this is how it manifests in my body, this is how I manage it and this is what it means for us tonight.
As I wait for her response, I'm proud of me for allowing myself to live fully despite fear. She thanks me for my honesty and says, “This is worth the risk.” And then, we talk about her sexual health history too. Finally able to fully relax into us, into our chemistry, our heat, I feel seen in a way that I haven't in a long while. Walking to the train the next morning with All Tonight still blasting on repeat in my headphones, I can't help but grin as I reminisce about the night before, what a way to ring in the New Year. I will save you the play by play, but let's just say, I definitely didn't spend that night under a man.
[cheers and applause]
Sarah [00:35:04] That was Devin Elise Wilson. Devin is a storyteller, model and recovering perfectionist. And no, nothing happened between her and the woman in the story after that night. She loves that it was just a moment in time. Devin runs a support group for people who are struggling with the stigma around being herpes positive. She's written a television comedy pilot to help change the narrative around herpes in the media. She wanted to call the TV show, Fuck, I have Herpes. But autocorrect changed it to Duck, I have Heroes. So, she went with that for the title. To see photos of Devin on that fateful night out, go to themoth.org.
After our break, a late-night slip and fall leads to a miracle, when The Moth Radio Hour continues.
Jay: [00:35:57] The Moth Radio Hour is produced by Atlantic Public Media in Woods Hole, Massachusetts.
Sarah: [00:36:03] You're listening to The Moth Radio Hour. I'm Sarah Austin Jenness. This is an hour all about night owls and what happens after dark. Our final story is also from that night in Greenwood Cemetery in Brooklyn. It's from Flash Rosenberg. And on this night in the fall of the pandemic, there was a stage set up between the mausoleums, and the moon cut through the darkness. Here's Flash Rosenberg, live at The Moth.
[cheers and applause]
Flash: [00:36:33] I don't think of drawing and photography, writing or performing as separate disciplines. I do them all. I'm an attention span for hire. I notice things in order to try to figure out what's going on. So, I was pretty excited when I had a chance to invent a class that I could teach at Cooper Union that took place entirely in the subways. The class was called Underground Creativity: Einstein on the D Train. And instead of assignments, which sounded too burdensome, we called what we did noticing games. Imagine you're sitting on the subway seat, and you're looking down, and the first game would be like, look at the shoes, guess the face. Look at the face, guess the shoes. Then we ramp it up a bit for a noticing game called Nuclear Subway.
Let's say, there's a nuclear accident and the only people left on earth are in this car with you. You have to pick someone to mate with to continue the human race. Now, this isn't about biology or gender. Just who in this car would you want to get together with to create a new world? Hmm, he's cute, but she's reading. [audience laughter] Well, and if your choice leaves the subway, then you have to pick someone else. Sometimes after class, I would stop at Keen's, which is a midtown steakhouse around the corner of my loft, so I could write down what I noticed the students noticing during the class.
Now, what am I doing at a steakhouse? Well, I'm their pet vegetarian. I would order the side dishes. I would get the spinach, the mashed potatoes, the salad. Once when I was there on a date, the guy observed, “This is never going to work out. You cannot even commit to an entree. You're never going to commit to a relationship.” You're right. I'm not married, I don't have kids and I didn't think I had a sense of humor until once I read in the New York Times science section that normal adults laugh about 15 times a day. I figured, “Whoa, I am way over the limit.” [audience laughter]
So, every time I laughed, I made a jotting down of what I laughed about in a notebook for two weeks. And, huh, it turns out I was the one making myself laugh. [audience laughter] So, I started doing comedy. One night,, I was at a club, and my great Aunt Leah, who was 89 at the time, had never seen me perform before, she comes up to me and says, “Don't let anyone in the family ever make you feel bad, because you didn't have kids. Because many people believe that children are the essence of life.” She said, “I wanted kids, too, but it didn't happen. You're like me. And the way I see it, those of us who don't have kids have been given some ability to figure out why we are here. So, that gift is a challenge.”
I was thinking, I've always wondered why I'm here. I mean, since I was age two when I was yelling out the fourth-floor window from our apartment, “Why am I here?” My mom came in like, “What?” “Well, I saw those people down on the sidewalk walking around. Why was I in my crib?” [audience laughter] So, one night after class, I didn't go to Keen's, but I ended up going to the Cornelia Street Café, because I was going to deliver a humorous toast at a little private cabaret show to celebrate a friend's birthday. I was dressed up. I like to dress up, because I'm a pathological optimist. I'm ready in case something good is going to happen. [audience laughter] I had my distinctive coat that I love so much that it looks like yarn that's pressed into it as if somebody scribbled with red, black and gray. I also think it's nice to dress up, because I feel some responsibility in a quiet way to help cheer up New York.
Well, the show ended late, and I was really tired and I was hungry. And so, on my way to the West 4th street subway to catch the uptown F, I stop and get about a dozen bagels and stick them in my backpack, so I can toast one when I get home. And on the way to the subway, I'm thinking, what am I doing? I mean, where's my big project? It just seems like I'm stomping on the ants and not feeding the elephants. I mean, is noticing a career? What's the point? So, I get out on the subway steps, go through the turnstile and I wait for the next train.
Next thing I see is bright blaring lights right above my face with people in masks wearing blue scrubs looking at me like they're gargoyles. There's tubes in my arms. Where am I? The nurse says, “You're in the emergency room at Bellevue.” She said “You fell on the tracks. You fell on the subway tracks.” Well, I always thought, what kind of a clueless person falls on the subway tracks? [audience laughter] Apparently, me. Well, the doctor assures that I'm fine. I'm going to be okay. Nothing's broken. There's no trauma. My heart is fine. He says, “You probably just fainted from exhaustion. You're good to go.” But I asked what happened. The nurse says, “It's the duty of a hospital to save your life, not your stories.” She hands me a plastic bag with that says personal belongings. And in it is my beautiful dress. That's all cut up. Because if you arrive at a hospital unconscious, they cut your clothes off, so they don't disturb you in case you have some broken bones. But by some wild luck, they did not cut my great coat.
Well, they hand me this XXX size sweats, wheelchair me to the curb, then leave me to fend for myself. I hail a cab. As soon as I get home, it's like 11:30 in the morning, I call my brother, because I didn't want him to worry since I missed our 07:30 AM daily call. “Hi, Ken. Sorry I missed our call. I was in the emergency room. I fell in the subway tracks, but I'm okay.” [audience laughter] And my brother says, “That is not a logical sentence in the English language. If you think you are okay, you are not okay.” He jumped up from his desk in his office in Wilmington, Delaware, took the next Amtrak train up to New York to take care of me. And his care was a big comfort.
But the whole day I had this shiver, chill, fever feeling, because I didn't know what happened. It was a mystery. I mean, I have no images. There was nothing that I noticed. Was I pushed? Where did it happen? Who saved me? Scarier than the fall itself was not knowing the story. Well, I figured I'd look online. Surely, somebody would have taken a cell phone snap, “A woman on the tracks would be more interesting than what you had for dinner.” But nothing. Two days later, I get a call from James, the manager at Keen's. “How are you?” That's strange, I thought. He's never called to find out how I am. James continues. “My waiter, Robert, rescued you the other night. Would you like to know the story?” “Ahh, yeah.” And so, my brother and I go over, sit with Robert and Robert explains.
He says, “I had just gotten off of work at 01:00 AM, and I go racing down the steps to catch the Uptown F. And oh, damn, the train is pulling out. I miss it. And so, I'm looking down the tracks to see when the next train might be coming. I notice in the distance a figure that's unsteady who seems to be trying to navigate around that really narrow part of the subway platform, around the stairs. And suddenly, that figure slips and slithers onto the tracks. [shocked] And, then I notice it's your coat. It's you. That's Flash.” And so, he rallies the few stragglers on the platform to come help. He said, the biggest guy jumped down. Somebody was guiding. He was pulling my arms. A woman was on the platform on her cell phone calling, 911. The next train is halted. My life is saved.
Well, being noticed on the subway tracks is all the celebrity anyone ever needs. [audience laughter] Plus, it's like a fashion tip, be noticeable. If I had been wearing my black puff coat, I would have been disguised as camouflaged as debris. I might still be down there. [audience laughter] And always carry bagels in your backpack. Gluten saved my life. They were like little life preservers, and probably are the reason why my back isn't broken. Then Robert continues to tell the story. He said, “When you were up on the platform, you were all apologetic. You were saying, ‘I'm fine. I'm going to walk home. I'm sorry to cause you so much trouble.’” Well, those of you who know me will not be surprised to hear that though unconscious, I was still talking. [audience laughter]
And then, he thought, well, he better be sure that I'm okay before he lets me go. So, he asked my name. Got it. And then, he asked for my emergency phone number. And somewhere in the befuddlement, emergency phone number-- I thought of the phone number that I was forced to memorize when I was a child during the Cuban missile crisis. Endicott 8-9-9-7-8. Well, the rescuers were much too young to know that used to be what phone numbers were. So, he thought, well, something must be wrong with her, so they called an ambulance. I'm never going to be able to thank Robert enough for saving my life. My brother tried. I mean, he took out his wallet and stuck it on the table at Keen's and said, “Just take whatever you want out of it. Max out the credit cards. “There's nothing that matters more to me. Nothing more valuable than my sister's life.”
The next morning, I was looking out of my fourth story window, and I was thinking, how does this affect me? How has this changed my life? Well, I do know that why I am here is a question I respect more now. When I was a teenager, I asked my Rabbi Krinsky, why am I here? Meaning, why am I going to Hebrew school for eight years? [audience laughter] And the rabbi said, “It's not about learning Hebrew. You know, all the Hebrew you needed to know you learned the first day.” I thought, “What? Shalom. And I was done?” He said, “No, no, no. Not shalom, but hineni,” the Hebrew word for here I am. He said, “When you are called upon during roll call and you answer to your name, you have agreed to be present. You have the ability to notice what there is to do.”
And then, he went on to say, “It's not about prayers either. The way to give thanks for being who you are is that you have to be exactly who you are.” And then, I thought about what Aunt Leah said after she saw me do that comedy performance. She said that I fulfilled what my grandfather could only wish for. She said her older brother, my papa, Rosie, he rescued the family. He brought them from Europe to America before the Nazis. But she said, “He didn't want to be a hero. What he wanted to do was perform on stage in New York City. So, hineni, here I am.”
[cheers and applause]
Sarah: [00:48:15] That was Flash Rosenberg. Flash draws, animates, cartoons, photographs, writes and performs. She says, she lives in Harlem with two turtles and infinite questions. To see photos of Flash in her unique coat and with that special waiter from Keens who saw it and saved her life, plus a collection of games invented by Flash to play on the subway, go to themoth.org.
We wish you many, many nights to remember. And that's it for this episode of The Moth Radio Hour. We hope you'll join us next time.
[overture music]
Jay: [00:49:04] This episode of The Moth Radio Hour was produced by me, Jay Allison, Catherine Burns and Sarah Austin Jenness, who also hosted the show and directed the stories in the hour along with Jenifer Hixson. Coproducer is Viki Merrick. Associate producer, Emily Couch. Additional education coaching by Catherine McCarthy.
The rest of The Moth’s leadership team includes Sarah Haberman, Meg Bowles, Kate Tellers, Jennifer Birmingham, Marina Klutse, Suzanne Rust, Brandon Grant, Inga Glodowski, Sarah Jane Johnson and Aldi Kaza. Moth Stories are true as remembered and affirmed by the storytellers.
Our theme music is by The Drift. Other music in this hour from Boombox, Tommy Guerrero, Boubacar Traoré, Anat Cohen, Jonathan Larson and Klezmer Juice. We receive funding from The National Endowment for the Arts.
The Moth Radio Hour is produced by Atlantic Public Media in Woods Hole, Massachusetts. Special thanks to our friends at Audacy, including executive producer, Leah Reis-Dennis. For more about our podcast, for information on pitching us your own story and everything else, go to our website, themoth.org.